Saturday, June 14, 2025

Sense from all justices. . .

June 5 the unanimous decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in Catholic Charities Bureau, Inc. v. Wisconsin Labor and Industry Review Commission struck down the 2024 Wisconsin Supreme Court’s decision against Catholic Charities, and, by extension, all religious organizations in that state.  The state's highest court had made the arbitrary judgment that Catholic Charities is not “operated primarily for religious purposes” and, therefore, ineligible for an unemployment tax exemption. SCOTUS judged the stat's decision had violated the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment and thus rendered a common sense victory for religious liberty throughout that state.  It is part of the liberal and progressive narrowing of the interpretation of religious freedom to include only the narrow exercise of liberty to worship and to exclude other works of religious organizations as not protected -- from schools to charitable works.  This trend to try and narrow the protection of religious freedom simply to the gathering for worship and evangelism has been ongoing for some time and flies in the face of history and practice today.  It is another example of the egregious nature of those on the left to render illegal things from feeding the hungry to housing the homeless to preaching in public to praying in the streets (as in front of abortion clinics).  This narrowing of what is religious and what is not is a threat and a real one to the religious liberty once unquestioned in America.  It represents another example of the courts defining in place of the churches what constitutes who they are as churches and what they do.  

This is, by the way, what is being appeals in the judgment rendered recently against the LCMS and the false idea that our corporate identity is somehow not who we are—even though it is our own self-declaration in the articles of incorporation, constitution, and bylaws of our Synod.  Every overreach by courts to narrow certain religious works or functions from the legal definition of what is “religious” of what is the self-understanding of the churches demands a vigorous opposition and I am happy for this SCOTUS rejection.  It should be noted that this court was not located in the traditional liberal enclaves of states and municipalities but in what might be described as the heartland of the US and the generally conservative Midwest.  Pay attention folks.  Elect people who are opposed to the liberal and progressive attempts to rein in our freedoms.

Friday, June 13, 2025

Pontius Pilate. . . who was he?

What a curious thing!  The creed proclaims the name not of patriarch or prophet but of the Roman Governor of Palestine.  Indeed, it might have been the Pontius Pilatus might never have been mentioned in history at all except for the creeds of Christendom.  He seems a rather large figure -- at least when viewed in relation to the death and resurrection of our Lord Jesus Christ -- but was in reality a rather small one.  We know his name more than we know the man.  Should we know more?

The story of Pilate was not quite the romantic tale of a poor man who made good.  He was born into privilege.  His career began with the status of equestrian (perhaps knight?).  For about forty years beginning 27 B.C. or so, Caesar Augustus saw the value of cultivating loyalty and embedding Roman values into the sons of those born free, with good character, and, of course, some money.  These would become suitable junior officers in war, would have opportunity to prove themselves as administrators, and become the back bench to greater imperial service.  Probably Pilate made some good friends among those well positioned in Rome and had a knack for advancement.  It is said he ended up prefect of Judaea upon recommendation of Lucius Aelius Sejanus, friend of the Emperor Tiberius.

It seems that Sejanus was well known for his antisemitic views and Pilate likely learned something from that.  One of Pilate’s most notorious acts to offend his subjects was to erecting images of the emperor all over the holy city of Jerusalem under darkness. Both Flavius Josephus and Philo both write about this and the reactions of the people of Jerusalem:

Hastening after Pilate to Caesarea, the Jews implored him to remove the standards from Jerusalem and to uphold the laws of their ancestors. When Pilate refused, they fell prostrate around his palace and for five whole days and nights remained motionless in that position.

In the face of the threat to be cut down by Pilate's troops, the Jews did not back down but insisted that they would rather die than violate their sacred law.

Thereupon the Jews, as by concerted action, flung themselves in a body on the ground, extended their necks, and exclaimed that they were ready rather to die than to transgress the law.  Overcome with astonishment at such intense religious zeal, Pilate gave orders for the immediate removal of the standards from Jerusalem.

The Pilate who rose to a position of some power by reading the signs around him backed down.  Perhaps this same learning curve was responsible for his own curiosity about Jesus, desire to engage Him in conversation, and the hesitance of his wife's own vision was enough to make him appear weak. Pilate had enough sense to know that the Jews had no real charges against Jesus except envy and jealousy.  He perceived that Jesus was innocent and thought having Jesus scourged might placate the crowd.  But when faced again with the unbending will of a people threatening revolt, Pilate bent.  But even Pilate would not accept responsibility for this murder:  “I am innocent of this man’s blood; see to it yourselves.”  He would, however, not be above mocking those who presented Jesus for death by putting a sign above Jesus, in Latin, Greek, and Hebrew, to let people know who Jesus was.  Curious about Jesus' death so soon (crucifixions were not designed to bring death on without a long period of suffering), Pilate sent word to Tiberius the reports of Jesus' resurrection.

What might have been a remarkable end with Pilate actually confessing Christ was not to be.  Though there is mythology about the conversion or saint among the Ethiopian Orthodox, Josephus tells us of a different conclusion. Historians say he continued a brutal reign until, in A.D. 36, the Samaritans on Mount Gerizim, and had to return to Rome to stand trial. Eusebius writes that Pilate eventually committed suicide (though there are disputes about this).

The creed confesses his name to mark the period in time in which the events of our salvation were wrought and not to honor him in any way.  In this confession, we are attesting to the factual character of the events we proclaim and acknowledging the sources, outside the New Testament, that report the same story of Jesus' suffering, death, and resurrection.  Pilate becomes the placeholder in time instead of some large figure.

Thursday, June 12, 2025

Performative humility. . .

When Jesus condemned the Pharisees whose visible piety betrayed an empty heart, He was not disdaining the piety but only that performative piety which is full of nothing.  For the record, Jesus observed the credible piety of the day and departed from it only when the so-called pious got it wrong (the Sabbath was made for man, remember).  Somewhere along the way we got so concerned with navel gazing and meditating on the genuineness of our piety that we stopped being pious.  I am speaking here not solely of Lutherans but of any Christian distinctives that were once the hallmark of our emerging identity in the world.

We do not pray or fast as we should.  No, it is not some kind of authoritarian demand but the Lord never says if we pray or fast but when.  We have adapted too well to the ways of the world and its insatiable demands to be satisfied that we no longer bend the knee in prayer or give up anything for any cause, not even the Lord.  Yes, I get it. The arcane and bizarre rules of Rome governing when to fast and when not were confusing and demanded a greater attention than the act of fasting itself but is that an excuse to indulge ourselves without regard to the godly discipline?   Yes, I understand.  Perfunctory prayers prayed because you have to pray them not only defeat the purpose of prayer but corrupt the words and make a mockery of our amen.  But is that cause to forget our Lord did not teach prayer as a method but as a particular set of words?  Rome and Wittenberg seem to be at the same place here with both traditions forgetting the tradition of their forefathers in favor of a casual relationship with God that requires nothing from us and deems sincerity the queen of all virtues.

We do not esteem the Church or the place where the liturgy of the faithful takes place as anymore or less than our own living rooms.  We carry in our designer coffees in our climate friendly cups and we cannot go an hour without our water jugs to keep us hydrated.  We are so very conscious of our hunger or thirst but almost oblivious to the wholly other place and the wholly other activity of that place in the liturgy.  It is always about us and our comfy dress and shoes and our expectations of soft seats only admits this unpleasant truth.  God would not want us to be anything but comfortable and do only that which reflects us and our tastes and preferences.  He definitely would not want us to say or do something our heart was not into and so this has become the rationale for believing little and looking even less holy.

We presume that our happiness is more important than marriage or children and so even Christians are having less of them both.  It is as if we have upped the ante in the world and created virtue out of the default positions of the masses -- choosing not to be committed and more comfortable in the digital world than reality.  The same is true of abortion and birth control.  It has become the unassailable right of the Christian to consign to the trash the babies God gives and to pursue safe sex over fruitful.  Once Christians made a mark for insisting upon the sanctity of marriage, upholding this marriage in a world of throw away spouses, and of resisting the cultural practice of devaluing the children.  Now Christians by their own admission look and act like those not of the Kingdom in their esteem of marriage and family -- or should I say lack of esteem. 

The problem is not how people treat us because we are Christians but that we give them so little evidence of our faith that it surprises them that we even believe.  Even a mere performative piety would be better than no piety at all.  No, I am not at all suggesting that we settle for a mere external faith content to live with an empty heart.  Instead, I am suggesting the radical nature of Jesus' own words.  We are called to believe and live in Him.  Lex orandi, lex credendi and its reverse were always the counterculture of Christendom.  We do not choose to show or to hide but to believe and live out the faith.  Yet how does this square with the digital reality of worship on a screen and the now usual attendance of once monthly?The comfort quotient now parses every part of piety from attendance in person to what we believe to how we live to how and what we pray.  God cannot be expecting to be impressed by our failure to even try in these areas and freedom was not given to make Christians less identifiable in an anonymous world.  Imagine that.  Performative humility -- as bad as it is -- almost makes you nostalgic for the days when we actually cared what people thought of our faith.  Then Pope Francis was good at performative humility but bad at being as generous and merciful behind closed doors as he wanted people to think him in the public square.  I am glad he no longer offers us the chance to hide behind a mask of humility or talk about it with words.  Instead, we all need to actually be holy as our Lord and the Father are holy.  This is the work of the Spirit, too.

Tuesday, June 10, 2025

The Holy Spirit sent to us. . .

Sermon for the Day of Pentecost, preached on Sunday, June 8, 2025. 

In the Gospels, St. John alone uses the title “Holy” in reference to the Spirit.  It is put in the mouth of St. John the Baptist who speaks of the One who is to come who baptizes with the Holy Spirit and fire.  As we heard today, tt is used in the Upper Room when Jesus promises the Paraclete, the Comforter, who will come in His name.  He is the Holy Spirit who will bring to mind all that He has said and deliver His peace which the world cannot give.  And then, four days later on Easter evening, Jesus says “Receive the Holy Spirit” to the apostles gathered behind closed doors.  With this ordination, He confers upon them and their successors the authority to forgive sins.

The Bible version we heard today translates Paraclete as Helper.  St. John alone uses this word of the Spirit.  The word itself is from two words – one that means along side of and the other call.  The Spirit is the one whom the Father sends in Jesus’ name to stand beside you and to call on your behalf.  Yes, He is your advocate but more than this He is the one who knows you, the weight of your hearts, the concerns of your minds, and the burdens of your souls.  He addresses you with the encouragement and strength to remain steadfast in the faith and endure to the end.

Helper is a pretty lame word in comparison to what the Spirit does.  Comforter is good but He does not just a pat on the back to say it will be okay.  The Spirit is the one who works to bring to completion that which was begun in us in our baptism.  He fights in us the good fight against the old flesh that clings to the ways of sin, hate, evil, selfishness, pride, and brings to maturity the new person created in Christ Jesus for good works now and for eternal life.  We cannot fight this fight alone.  The Spirit works in us and for us to finish Christ’s new creation.

See how He worked to bring this rag tag band of fearful disciples into the mighty voices who brought the voice of the Gospel to the ends of the earth.  See how He worked to keep St. Peter the denier from despair and planted him in hope through the power of forgiveness.  See how He worked to answer the doubts and longing of St. Thomas from stealing his heart and killing his faith.  See how He worked to turn Saul the destroyer into St. Paul the zealous, sending him to the known corners of the empire to call the world to faith.

See how He worked in you.  You who were dead in trespasses and sin, condemned to an eternity of death, but rescued by God’s mighty power in baptism.  You to whom He has given the voice of faith to give consent to this faith and courage to proclaim it with your lips and give evidence of it in your lives.  You who were given the ears to hear and minds to recognize the voice of Your Good Shepherd and follow Him.  You who were hungry whom He brought today here where the Bread of Life feeds you till you want know more.  You who were lost in temptation and shame whom He restored by bringing you where forgiveness is the language spoken and restoration replaces punishment.

Until that day when Christ comes in His glory, He has given you the Holy Spirit to comfort you with this forgiveness and to strengthen you in faith through His Word and Sacraments.  He is daily at work bringing to fullness what began in water empowered by the Word, connecting you to Christ’s death and resurrection. This same Holy Spirit who was the inspiration of all the prophets, the courage of the patriarchs, the sender of the apostles, and the prompter of the holy writers to testify to Christ, now addresses you with this Word. 

We trust those words even though we do not now see Him but we know Him.  They are not simply words but the fountain of doctrine and life.  Once in the baptismal waters the Spirit drowned us so that we might be raised with a new name and with a righteousness to cover all our sin.  Once we were no people but the Holy Spirit has made us God’s own family, with the gift of salvation and the inheritance of eternal life.  

He does not wait for us to call upon Him but has been sent to us.  He calls us to be the children of God, gathers us into His Church, enlightens us with the light of salvation, and sanctifies us to be His own.  We who could not by our own reason or strength, believe in Jesus Christ, now love Him as well and love all that He loves.  We serve God by serving our neighbor in His name, by forgiving one another as He has forgiven us, and by loving with the sacrificial love that has redeemed us.

Forgiveness is the key to opening the door to belonging and in belonging we hear Christ pray for us and learn from Him to pray.  He is our Advocate before the Father and the Son, praying the blood of Christ on our behalf.  He brings our prayers to the Father in Jesus’ name and teaches us to pray – not as those who offer a laundry list of wants before the Father but on behalf of the world, our neighbors, and all those in need.  He delivers to us the clothing of Christ’s righteous that we might be righteous and promises that the prayers of the righteous avail much.  When words escape us, He helps us pray when words do not come and who He grunts and groans into the pleading of the faithful to the God who is always faithful.

So day by day, hour by hour, minute by minute, we live and the Spirit is at work in us through it all.  Though our holiness is half finished and our journey to eternity is not complete, the Spirit helps us wait for that time when our flesh and sin will be buried forever with all their uncleanness and we no longer need to be forgiven.  Waiting for that day when Christ will come and we shall rise, in perfect holiness, there to receive eternal life.  We are not there yet but that is where the Spirit is leading us and for this the Spirit preserving us in faith.

All this begun in us until He brings it to completion on the day the Lord comes in His glory.  That is the Spirit’s work.  God grant it for Jesus sake.  Amen 

A small part of the bigger thing. . .

When the bishops met in Nicea to confront Arius and other false expressions of God, there were some there who had the idea that God was this ousias or substance of which a part could be found in the Father and in the Son and in the Holy Spirit.  God, however, we the stuff from which it all came and those who had a little bit of it were not the same as God.  It was a philosophical solution to a theological question and the Church said that this was not the catholic faith, not the faith of the apostles, and, most importantly, not the faith of the Scriptures.  The Nicene Creed was then an attempt to summarize what was catholic and apostolic and Scriptural in expressing who God is and the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as this God.  I would highly recommend John Behr's The Way to Nicea as a solid introduction to what was being confessed by the orthodox and by the false teachers in the prelude to Nicea's answer.

I wonder if it is not the same when we speak about the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church.  There are those who would see this as something above and different from the individual parts, much in the same way God was something from which little bit flowed out into the three persons of the Trinity but God remained wholly other.  Some people are all hot and bothered about whether or not they are part of that one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church -- as if it were not a reality in itself but showed up in bits and pieces.  Even those on the conservative end of the spectrum speak this way and certainly the liberal liturgicals.  Are we a part of the catholic Church?

Rome has its own answer which I will not elaborate upon here.  Suffice it to say that key to their answer is being under the authority of the Pope.  The East has its own problems with that, of course, just as we Lutherans do.  But the false part of it all is the idea that the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church is divided up into little parts here and there and little bits and pieces of the catholic faith are present here and there and everywhere.  That is not how the early Christians understood it and it is not how we should understand it either.  The Church was either catholic or it wasn't (and therefore heretical).  You did not have little bits and pieces of the catholic Church here or there -- not in the early understanding of geographic understandings nor in the modern idea of different communions or jurisdictions (Lutheran, Methodist, Episcopalian, etc.).  The creed from Nicea functioned to point where that one, holy, Catholic and apostolic Church was and where it was not.  It did not point to part of it but the wholeness of it.  You cannot have the catholic faith in bits and pieces.  It either is or is not catholic.  It is not present in parts or bits and pieces but the whole is present in its wholeness or not at all.

Being catholic is not being a part of something bigger but that which is the bigger is present in this particular place.  You cannot be catholic but ordain women or be catholic but promote same sex marriage or be catholic but not profess the Real Presence.  All of these are connected.  You cannot be catholic on some things but not on others.  The catholic faith does not live in parts or pieces but the whole lives in the wholeness.  I wish we would stop wondering if we were in or part of the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church and were intentional about confessing the whole of this faith without reservation or hesitation.  How odd it is to wish to be a part of something whole but at the same time to disagree with some of what lives in that wholeness?  It is like being Trinitarian but not confessing the Son or the Spirit as fully God.  If you do that you are not Trinitarian.  Plain and simple.  So you cannot be catholic or as some wish to say part of the catholic Church but hold to different opinion about Scripture or the ordination of women or legitimize same sex desire or the presence of Christ in the Eucharist or baptismal regeneration.  As soon as you put a question mark where God has put a period, you are automatically not catholic.  Period.  Rome, Lutheranism, Anglicanism, etc., do not each have a part of the catholic faith nor are they parts of the one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church.  You either are that or not.  That is what the Lutheran Reformation was really about.  The Lutherans insisted that by expressing an authority above the Scriptures and confessing doctrines about which Scripture knows nothing, Rome had ceased to be catholic and they intended to actually be catholic in doctrine and in practice.

Monday, June 9, 2025

The quality of mercy. . .

The quality of mercy is not strain'd.
It droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven
Upon the place beneath. It is twice blest:
It blesseth him that gives, and him that takes.
'Tis mightiest in the mightiest; it becomes
The throned monarch better than his crown.
His scepter shows the force of temporal power,
The attribute to awe and majesty,
Wherein doth sit the dread and fear of kings;
But mercy is above this sceptered sway;
It is enthroned in the heart of kings;
It is an attribute to God himself;
And earthly power doth then show likest God's
When mercy seasons justice. 
wrote William Shakespeare.

I fear we do not understand mercy.  We live in times in which mercy has become muddy, cloudy, and confused.  Like so many other things, it has become detached from that which is its context.  Mercy does not eliminate judgment.  Indeed, judgment is the only context in which mercy makes sense.  Mercy does not wish the sin away but acknowledges the sin for what it is.  Today, it is hard to speak of sin without being accused of having no compassion, no heart, and no mercy.  It is no wonder that God's mercy has become the judgment from God that sin does not matter anymore or that God does not care about holiness and righteousness.

Mercy presumes that sin exists, that it is horrid and terrible, and that there is a day when sinners will be held accountable.  Mercy does not mean there is no sin, that nothing is wrong, that we have no culpability for evil.  The gift of mercy is not to wish away restraint.  Just the opposite, mercy means that sin does indeed exist but that there is a remedy for sin and a medicine for its death.  We give thanks to God not because He no longer counts sin as bad or sinners as responsible but because He has visited our sin and its punishment upon Him who willingly came to bear it up for us all.  Mercy does not mean that sin does not exist but that God has not allowed it to have its last word over us.  We need mercy precisely because sin matters.  Maybe you are better than I am but the reality is I have no chance for salvation apart from the mercy of God revealed to me in Christ Jesus, His Son.   It is only through grace and mercy that we are set free from sin, healed from its death, and raised to dwell with God in His presence forevermore.  The Scriptures say, But nothing unclean will ever enter it [heaven], nor anyone who does what is detestable or false (Rev 21:27).  We are given in mercy the clothing of righteousness in Christ, a righteousness not our own.

Mercy certainly does not mean there is no judgment, no accountability, and no path of impunity in which we can hide.  There will be a day of judgment and this cannot be escaped.  We need mercy precisely because there is a day of judgment coming.  If there is no hell, there is no mercy.  If there is no prospect of punishment, there is no need for mercy.  So, thanks be to God for His mercy is freely given and fully able to overcome the mountain of our sin and its shadow of death!  Our glory is not that we have overcome sin but that God has shown mercy to those who do not deserve it, have done nothing to merit it, and have nothing to offer with it.  It is a fool who suggests that mercy means there is nothing really wrong, that sin has no consequence, or that judgment will not take place.  God has answered our sin not with the shrug of His shoulders but with the shoulders of Christ, outstretched in suffering, to pay in full our debt of sin and to clothe us with an alien righteousness which alone can commend us to the Father.

 

Sunday, June 8, 2025

What does it matter?

One of the congenital defects of the liturgical movement is our attempt to make things easier for people not accustomed to or even alien to rite, ritual, ceremony, chant, postures of worship, vestments, etc...  We tend to treat these as strong tastes that must be learned in small portions.  That is why so often we never get there.  We take such small steps forward that we really do not move at all.  It does not help that our pastors are counseled at seminary either not to make needed changes in bad liturgical practice or to make them very slowly and to explain them until people would rather have the practice than the explanation any longer.  It surely begs for a long pastorate.

Underneath it all I fear is not that we do not like nose bleed high church.  No, underneath it all I fear is the fact that we are really not convinced that it is worth it.  We do not value as we ought the grand mystery that takes place in the liturgy as the means of grace unfold before us the very presence of the mighty God manifesting the fruits of Christ's redeeming work in earthly means.  The whole idea that this must happen in 59 and 1/2 minutes is testament to the fact that we resent giving God any time and we do not really believe He is worthy more nor are the gifts given and received in the liturgy.  The pandering to the sound of music outside the Church more than within the sacred choral, chant, and hymnic tradition is due to the fact that we don't believe the music matters nor what it says (or sings).  All music has become elevator muzak as background track for something which is nice but not so nice it should inconvenience you.  Vestments and chanting are resented because we resent the whole idea that what happens in God's House is different from what happens in our own living rooms -- we resent sacred vestments and vessels as well as chant because the idea of the sacred offends us.  Truth be told we are more at home in the secular.  God forbid you introduce incense because we value our false images of health and our sense of taste more than we do any Biblical image or passage -- God help us if heaven does not have a non-smoking section!

In the end, if we believe it is simply in what happens on the altar to the bread and wine then should not what surrounds the altar be of the highest quality and attention that we can provide?  If the Scriptures are God's Word and the sermon has a sacramental purpose of addressing us with that living voice of God applied to our daily lives, why must it be brief or funny or entertaining?  If the Eucharist truly is what we confess it to be, should we not spend time praying and preparing to receive it?  If God allows us to be guest and feeds us with the foretaste of heaven's eternal food, should we not dress up instead of dressing down?  If this music flows out of God's entrance into our world, why would we expect our music to be imposed upon His?  If the pastor (priest) is acting in persona Christi to address us with God's Word and wash us clean at God's font and feed us from his very hands the flesh and blood of Christ, why would we not honor him with our attention and kneel in adoration before the heavenly door that opens in each Divine Service?

How do you explain this to people?  I wish I knew.  How do you explain loving air conditioning and a kitchen and hot water over living in a cave?  Is it not obvious and self-apparent?   Unless we are not really convinced and so because we do not value more than anything God's presence and gift within the Divine Service we are not sure what to say in defense of it except we like it?  I like a grilled cheese sandwich but I also like prime rib and I know the difference.  Do our explanations fall short because we cannot really explain the difference between worship music that sounds like Cold Play and chant or because we are not sure why all the time needs to be spent in church as opposed to on our screens?  If God is not worth our being inconvenienced, He is not worth much at all.  It is tiresome that we find ourselves on the defense when it comes to rite, ritual, and reverence.  We ought to admit it.  Either you believe God is worth it or you don't, what God gives in the Divine Service is worth it or it isn't, and matters of eternal salvation are even more important than our feelings in the moment or they are not.  The decay of Christendom will not be hastened by too much attention to ceremony but it will surely die for banal homilies on boring subjects in white washed buildings devoid of anything that points us beyond ourselves. 

Saturday, June 7, 2025

An easy day. . .

I wish I could take credit for it but I read it somewhere.  The easiest day of your life is yesterday.  Today and tomorrow are much harder.  How true that is.  As soon as the day is over, its hardness begins to be softened in our memories.  My grandparents actually remembered the camaraderie of families working together more than they recalled the lack of things during the Great Depression.  The stories of things that sent us to emergency rooms or running in fear end up being told for laughs at family gatherings and among friends.  It is strange but true.  Yesterday was the easiest day of your life.

Today is filled with challenges.  Just waking up and making a beginning on the day can be hard. It has gotten to be difficult to talk myself into turning on the news as my wife and I gather at the breakfast table.  The news is always bad.  Who wants to hear it.  Planes crash, cars collide, stocks fall, inflation rises, the world battles, leaders argue, and the weatherman always gets it wrong.  Who wants to hear it? Working to find that perfect balance of job and home, work and life, is a constant problem throughout the day.  Sometimes figuring out what you want to eat is a task big enough to rob us of the very pleasure of eating.  Today is never easy except when it fades into yesterday.  I wish I could count the number of times when i woke up thinking the day was going to be okay only to hear tornado sirens or get the devastating phone calls announcing disease or death or finding out the car won't start or co-workers are all out for the day for one reason or another.  All my best laid plans come to naught when I think that today is going to be just fine.  Only when today passes into yesterday can I make that kind of judgment upon the day.

Tomorrow is even worse.   I cannot begin to tell you what hopes I have had for the days to come only to see them disappoint me over and over again.  Sometimes the uncertainty of tomorrow steals away my rest and I am left to toss and turn sleepless upon my bed and all for a day that is not yet.  The dread of what might be is so often worse than reality but it is just as often not as bad as things will get.  The sun will not always come out tomorrow but you can bet your bottom dollar tomorrow will not fail to disappoint your hopes and realize you worst fears.  I remember my Uncle Norris' funeral when the pastor described my uncle bending down to the dirt of his farm and expressing wonder over the mystery of life.  He obviously did not know my uncle or any farmer or all the rest of us who looks to the future with a mix of dread and surety that God will not get it right (too much rain or too little and if it is a good crop then it will go for a bad price).  My uncle was not a bad guy.  We all look at the calendar that way.  It is out of our control and that is its worst fault.

It is as if God has designed us to depend upon Him.  It is as if He proves Himself to us every day by turning the fight of today and the anxiety of tomorrow into the peace of yesterday which not only over but better than it was, at least in retrospect.  Thanks be to God we have only the challenges of the day to torment us and the what ifs of tomorrow to haunt us.  If we were in charge, it would be even worse.  But God can deal kindly with memory and teach us that its worst was not so bad and its best was not so good that it cannot be equaled.  There is some peace in that if we allow it.

Thursday, June 5, 2025

Self-serving PR

I have been asked to teach a continuing ed course in August in two locations.  The information is listed below.  Take a gander and if you are interested, sign up and join us.  It is not only for pastors but also for lay folks as well.

August 4–6, 2025 in Auburn, MI &

August, 12-14 in Cupertino, CA 

The Rev. Larry A. Peters is a native of Nebraska and graduated from St. John’s College, Winfield, Kansas, Concordia Senior College, Fort Wayne, Indiana, and Concordia Theological Seminary, Fort Wayne (1980). He vicared on Long Island and served his first call in Cairo, New York, before moving to Clarksville, Tennessee, where he has served Grace Lutheran Church as senior pastor for thirty-two years. He is now pastor emeritus of Grace. In 2017 Concordia Theological Seminary recognized him as alumnus of the year. He has served as a circuit visitor in the Atlantic and Mid-South districts, is currently chairman of the Synod’s Commission on Constitutional Matters, sits on the Synod’s Commission on Handbook, and is also secretary of the Mid-South district. He has also served on the planning committees for the Synod’s Institute for Liturgy, Preaching, and Church Music for the last ten years. Pastor Peters has published many periodical articles and served as a contributor to a number of CPH volumes. He is the author of the popular blog, Pastoral Meanderings. Pastor Peters has been married to his wife, Amy, for more than forty-six years, and they have three adult children and two grandchildren. He is currently trying to figure out what retirement means.  

At All Times and in All Places: All God's People Pray 

More words about prayer can be found in the Scriptures than about most other topics, and yet God’s people struggle with what it means to pray. This course will examine the practice of prayer among God’s Old Testament people, through the time of Christ, through the history of Christianity, and down to the present day. What is prayer? What does it mean to pray? How do we pray? How did the people of God order their prayer lives before us? What is the difference between and what is the connection with the individhttps://witness.lcms.org/the-magazine/ual prayer lives of God’s people and the common prayers of God’s people together? What does God’s Word teach us about prayer? This course will help participants learn and appreciate the lessons of the past on the practice and discipline of prayer both as individuals and as a people gathered together for worship and prayer. All of us are both amateurs and professionals when it comes to praying, and this course is both for those who lead and teach God’s people to pray and for the people of God in their discipline of prayer throughout the circumstances and places of life.  

Location:    Grace Lutheran Church 303 Ruth St. Auburn, MI 48611 To download the registration form, click here.  

Lutheran Church of Our Savior 5825 Bollinger Rd. Cupertino, CA 95014  To download the registration form, click here.

Coordinators:  Rev. Aaron T. Schian Email: aaronschian@yahoo.com Phone: (607) 972-5792  & Rev. John Bestul Phone: 408.252.0345 Email: pastorjbestul@lcos.org 

Schedule is available from the Seminary or from the pastors who are coordinating.  See you there!

 

A solution with a new problem. . .

Everyone with a brain will agree that the significant decline in manufacturing jobs have left the US vulnerable.  Whether you think tariffs help or hurt, it is a problem that we need to solve.  I read a while ago that there are some 500K manufacturing jobs waiting for people to fill them but few applicants.  Some will read this as a need for immigrant workers.  We could become a new Sweden or Germany with a guest worker program but that is a solution with its own drawbacks.  We could hope for a turnaround in the declining birth rate but that would take a generation to hit our labor force.  It is not simply that there are not enough people but blue collar jobs have no cache in the labor market even if they do provide a substantial compensation and benefits package.

Our problem today is that we abhor work.  Work used to be that which defined America -- not simply our ingenuity or our dedication but the way we valued the labor of our hands.  The move to a mechanized manufacturing world and even agriculture has shifted thinking away from work with our hands.  The service industry has expanded greatly but this is more often seen as an entry level job than where you end up.  I spoke with an HVAC tech who told me this was just the gig he got to pay the bills but he wants to do something different.  He is in his early twenties and earns far more than I did as a pastor in my early career (even accounting for the different times).  He has a large house, toys, his wife works as a professional, and he feels like his job, while it certainly pays the bills, does not have the aroma of success around it.  Look at the numbers of openings for plumbers, electricians, and the building trades.  It is hard work, to be sure, but it has the smell of need rather than accomplishment in our culture.  I spoke with another twenty-something who gave up a very lucrative job as a carpenter to work in a service job because he found it more to his liking to have set hours, three days off a week, and a predictable schedule all year round rather than the higher earnings.  Work is not valued like it once was or should be.

I suspect that this goes hand in hand with those who see domestic life as not only dull and routine but low class.  Parenting costs so much more than it rewards in the eyes of young people today.  Marriage is also evaluated by the same measure of rewards for investment.  Volunteerism once was the hallmark of the society of America but it too has waned and those you once counted upon to do good works without pay are hard to come by.  Even Salvation Army bell ringers are paid.  The work of helping our neighbor is less done with gloves and tools than with donations to a cause.  How odd that we a go fund me cause works while sign up sheets for delivering meals on wheels has the same old predictable names.  Ours is not simply an immigration crisis or a reproductive crisis but a crisis of values.  We do not value work and it shows.  In order for factories to have people working in them, we will have to reevaluate that labor and esteem it more highly or no one will want to work in them.  In this area we show ourselves far from the Biblical milieu where work was given in creation long before the Fall into sin and had a noble character to it.  Maybe because of sin but certainly do to a change in the way we look at work and value labor, we no longer think it is a good thing.  We still want what we want but we don't seem to want to work that hard to get it.  This is another part of the whole idea of vocation that is changing and not for the good. 

Wednesday, June 4, 2025

Misguided. . . or not

A few days after Easter, Kelly Armstrong, the Republican governor of North Dakota, vetoed a bill passed by the state legislature that would have required public schools (and libraries) to ensure that books containing pornographic and other sexually explicit content are inaccessible to children.  According to Governor Armstrong, it was a  "misguided attempt to legislate morality."   Across the miles to the East, some parents were in court trying to prevent their school district from requiring that their sons and daughters be required to read storybooks and participate in lessons promoting “Pride” parades, same-sex marriage, “non-binary” identity, transgenderism and sex-change procedures, and drag shows.  According to them this was also a "misguided attempt to legislate morality" and one which intervened between them and their children in an overreach of law.  Now to be sure, there was no book banning involved in either case but the simple requirement in the first that children under a certain age would have their access to pornographic or sexually explicit content restricted until an age appropriate for it (is there an age appropriate for porn and sexually explicit content???) and in the other to allow the parents to opt their children out of such events, materials, and promotions.  It should have been a no-brainer but it wasn't.  

The schools and libraries of our nation are not neutral places because there is no such thing.  Leaving pornographic material and sexually explicit material on the shelves without age appropriate restriction is not being neutral.  Bypassing parental rights and responsibility so that their children are compelled to participate in the cutting edge of sexual and gender ideology is not neutral.  And, pardon my boldness, but Kelly Armstrong is just plain wrong.  The entire purpose of laws IS to legislate morality.  That is exactly why we have laws against the abuse of minors, violence, murder, defamation of character, rape, public lewdness, etc...  There is no such thing as a morally neutral zone -- not even the college campus and its safe place for students who feel threatened by ideas that conflict with their own.  Nope.  It simply does not exist nor should it.

The last thing we need is a morally free or neutral zone in our schools or anywhere else for that matter.  It may accord with some libertine ideal but it is foolishness beyond idiocy and whoever proposes such is a major league food.  Conservatives need to awaken to the fact that they have no safe place in this debate.  Either you are for children and parental responsibility and choice or you are for the progressive goal of bypassing the parents and instilling an institutional morality which accords with the social mores of the moment.  There is no neutral zone there, either.  Laws exist to impose morality upon the immoral.  That is not the question at hand but whose morality prevails.  If there are parents who believe that porn and sexually explicit material is appropriate for their toddlers, children, and youth, they have every right within their homes to make it available to their children.  The school cannot and should not be an accomplice in this.  If there are parents who believe that porn and sexually explicit material is always inappropriate for their toddlers, children, and youth, they have every right to expect that this will not be violated by another authority.  The school must respect this.  Remember, this is not about a morality neutral zone but a question of whose morality is in play.  

I hate to even think about those parents who would subject their children to such adult and prurient and steal their childhood from them in this way but I cannot abide those on the other side stealing the authority from the parents over their children thus presuming to know better what is good for them.  Where is our common sense?  Once there was a time in which people would have presumed that schools were to be places of learning around a curriculum of reading, writing, and arithmetic.  Now, it would seem, we insist upon making schools into experiments and labs in pursuit of a freedom which no child really wants or is equipped to deal with and we cover it with the lie that it is morally neutral.   

Monday, June 2, 2025

Hey, I know her!

Here is a shout out to someone many of you know by reputation and writing if not personally.  I have had the privilege of her acquaintance for a while and was surprised to be reviewing the news on my phone only to see her with the White House Press Corps.   In February 2025, the White House announced that it would determine which outlets are allowed access to the president, instead of the White House Correspondents' Association.  In the past, as well as today, it has been a sometimes eclectic mix of reporters from major news outlets to smaller print establishments.  Our own confessional Lutheran and well connected journalist, Mollie Hemingway joined the group.  Way to go, Mollie!  We are not only proud of you but encourage you to keep fulfilling your vocation both as Editor-in-Chief at The Federalist and in the White House Briefing Room while also managing the vocations of wife and mother.  God bless you!

Sad news from Nebraska. . .


In fulfillment for the requirement of a final recital as part of his music degree, a doctoral student at the University of Nebraska recently orchestrated a drag performance mocking the Roman Catholic Mass (and, by extension, the Lutheran Divine Service).  Imitations of the ordinary, the Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus, and Agnus Dei, were performed at Our Saviour’s Lutheran Church of Lincoln (an ELCA congregation).  The doctoral student, identified as Joseph Willette, said via Instagram that this performance “truly feels like the culmination of [his] past couple of years studying music composition as well as gender, sexuality, and queer communities.”  “At the core of this work lies the juxtaposition of the holy and the profane, the sacred and the sinful,” he said.  The “sacred” of the Mass was contrasted with the “sinful” in “the queer imagery and art forms,” Willette said.  “Mass of Perpetual Indulgence for chamber orchestra, electronics, soprano solo, and drag performer was written to bridge the gap between queerness and spirituality, to sanctify queer people and celebrate our lives and communities,’’ states the description on the video published to YouTube.  After the performance, Willette earned a doctorate of musical arts in composition at the Glenn Korff School of Music.  

While it is unknown if the congregation knew or understood what was going on in this performance, the ELCA is at the forefront of LGBTQ+ causes among Lutherans.  There was no distancing of the congregation, the school of music and its faculty, or the University of Nebraska from this work -- at least at the time I wrote this.  One can only presume that mocking Christianity in its various forms is the one bigotry left to be acceptable in America.  What is even more pathetic is that the whole university system owes its very life to the work of the Church in establishing such schools from the medieval times through the present day.  Speaking as a Nebraskan by birth, I am saddened that this is what passes for educational endeavor and reward or for musical accomplishment at the University.  It has been widely known and lauded for its musical schools and faculty in the past but certainly the diversity ideal has impacted what it was in favor of mere shock and offense.  How sad.

Sunday, June 1, 2025

Why so uncomfortable?

Garrison Keillor pokes fun at Lutherans whose virtue seems to be downsizing.  Perhaps this is a truth that hurts a bit.  We do seem somewhat embarrassed by our own churches and even our Confessions are not without some sort of apology.  It is as if we are surprised that anyone who was not born into Lutheranism would want to become Lutheran!  As if that were not enough, we are also uncomfortable around the topic of sanctification and almost embarrassed by our own good works -- whether feeble or not.  We love to talk about justification but a strange hush flows through the room when the topic is our growth in holiness.  I have heard it said and said it myself that Lutherans love all things in moderation -- even sin and righteousness.  Again, the joke is close to home.  You once commonly heard the pastor pray before his sermon:  “These are Your Words, Heavenly Father. Sanctify us by the Truth. Your Word is Truth. Amen.”   Now not so much.  It is not the absence of the prayer that is concerning but forgetting that the goal of the Word is also to sanctify us as well as justify.  It is as if we have skipped over the line in the Our Father Hallowed be Thy name.

Take, for example, the way Lutheranism seems downright scandalized by the prospect of an ascetic life or monasticism.  Sure, I get it.  The errors and abuses of Luther's day have become the only way we view these things but is that our problem or theirs?  Why would we have a problem with those who not only choose the single life (one our Confessions esteem holier than marriage?) and go another step beyond to live a relatively simple and even meager life without all the frills that so easily engage our imaginations and become our solitary pursuits?  Why would we automatically have suspicions about a group of such individuals who might live in a monastic life sharing the duties and becoming each other's counsel as they navigate through a world of abundance to seek Christ alone as the bread of life?  But we do.  That is our knee jerk reaction to such an idea.

It is no wonder then that while we preach wonderfully about God's justification of the sinner, we don't have much to say about growth in grace, in holiness of life and speech, and of the purifying of the mind and heart on our way to the destination God has appointed with Him in Christ?  Indeed, sometimes people have come to me over the years with the basic question of how they should live as a Christian.  It would seem that we have not given as much guidance to them as we should.  Adolf Koberle's book is marvelously titled The Quest for Holiness.  It should be the subtitle of all our lives in Christ. We struggle with the whole idea of holiness and are quick to remind those interested that they are still sinners and wrestle with the Old Adam until Christ's final deliverance through death to everlasting life.  It is like a warning to people that they would be better to live more easily within the boundaries of moderation than to become zealous for good works and growth in holiness.  Nobody likes a zealot.

Justification is always complete, sanctification is always being completed -- it would seem that we should not have to remind ourselves of this but we do.  Sanctification is God's work in us but it is not without our cooperation.  God does not impose holiness upon us as a condition of our justification but the fruits of our gracious life with God flow out in good works and growth in holiness.  Yes, we all know that it is no straight line ascending to God but the rescue of His grace in the midst of our fallen lives constantly restoring us even as He has declared us righteous in Christ.  I just wish we did not have such a penchant for justification at the expense of also speaking of how then we should live.  Asceticism is not simply living without or poverty would be a sacrament.  Asceticism is living always knowing that this world is passing away, its joys are good but pale in comparison to the eternal that awaits, its institutions and even vocations so necessary to today will be transcended in the life to come, and that man lives by the bread God has provided in the flesh of Christ that is our food.  Asceticism is never the goal of living so that we no longer need Christ and His atonement but rather living in Christ as fully as possible while living this side of heaven and so that His life will bear its appointed fruit in us and through us.  When we speak of good works and growth in holiness we need to stop beginning the conversation with a "yes, but..." and speaking more fully of the because.

Rome seems to be uncomfortable talking about justification but then again Trent anathematized the very words of Scripture in this regard.  Lutherans seem to talk only of justification and so the world sees a secular piety in us and we find ourselves strangely tongue tied when trying to say otherwise.  Vocation hits the mark, to be sure.  As Swedish theologian Einar Billing has characterized it and Gene Veith reminded us, Luther moved those “spiritual disciplines” out of the monastery and into the vocations of secular life.  Poverty became thrift and hard work, the discipline of paying bills and trying to make ends meet.  Chastity became faithfulness in marriage.  Obedience became submission to the law.  Furthermore, the monastic practices of prayer, meditation, and worship–while still central to every Christian’s vocation in the Church—also moved into the family and the workplace.  Or did they?  The loss of our children to unbelief, the discomfort we also have with roles in marriage, and the temptation we fall into of describing our own self-fulfillment as primary seem to indicate that have not been so successful here.  That is a discomfort we need to get over.  Soon.

Saturday, May 31, 2025

As Valpo Turns. . .

There was a time when all Lutheran colleges wished they were Valpo.  Begun as a Methodist school in 1859, the city raised $11,000 to bring it there. Opened in the fall of 1859 with 75 students, it was one of the first coeducational colleges in the nation.  Though money problems led to the closing of the school in 1871, it re-opened two years later as  the Northern Indiana Normal School and Business Institute.  After more money problems, the university almost sold to the Ku Klux Klan, but the deal was stopped and in July 1925, the Lutheran University Association, affiliated with the Lutheran Church–Missouri Synod, took over ownership of the school. The association wanted to create an academic institution not controlled by any church denomination even though it was strongly associated with the LCMS until the past fifty years or so. 

In 1940, O. P. Kretzmann became president of the university and remade the school into what it was.  Its glory days during his 28 years in office saw the school purchase 90 acres  near US Highway 30, build the iconic chapel which remains one of the largest in America, and increase the enrollment to more than 40,000.  Since his death, the school has slowly been moving away from the LCMS and its vaunted honor code and history of excellence.  Now, without a president, the school has fallen on hard times.  There are half the students there were and no more money.  They have sold off assets (in the midst of great controversy) in order to renovate dorms and make campus improvements.  Now the Valparaiso City Council has approved the school's issuance of up to $117 million in general obligation bonds for some campus renovations and to refinance university debt.

It would seem that nobody wants to be Valpo anymore.  Adrift from its roots and legacy under Kretzmann, the school has had trouble attracting students, keeping faculty, and sustaining its once core academic programs.  In essence, it is a school trying to figure out who they are and why anyone would pay a premium price to go there. In 2021, Valparaiso retired the "Crusaders" nickname because of the "negative connotation and violence associated with the Crusader imagery" and adopted Beacons as its new identity.  It no longer shines much light but is looking to find a little to guide it out of its myriad of problems.  There are Concordias in the LCMS larger than Valpo and on better footing.  Their last President was Roman Catholic in affliation and on one has mistaken Valpo for a Lutheran school for a very long time.  How sad.  Valparaiso University's bond rating was dropped by Moody's down two notches to a junk rating.  It was one more slap in the face of a once vaunted reputation and identity that has collapsed.  Diversity takes its toll on another educational institution.  When there is nothing left to sell and nobody left willing to lend money to them, the junk status of the school will match its bond rating.

Friday, May 30, 2025

How odd. . .

It seems that the question of what to do with Genesis and its account of creation is a never ending question.  Or, perhaps, its answer is not what the questioners will accept and so the work of debunking what God has said continues.  On the one hand what God has said is attacked as myth -- except that nothing in Genesis suggests that it is telling us anything except fact and history.  Add to that the fact that myth is not a genre of the Old Testament people of God.  Add to the fact that no one in the New Testament, including Jesus, treats the Biblical account of creation as anything but fact and history.  The other hand is to attack the text.  God is not responsible for what was written -- only men working within their own limited, uneducated, unscientific, and unsophisticated understanding of things.  Of course, this begs the question of what in the Bible actually does represent God's Word and what is only the word of man.  If reason and science are the criteria for what is God's and what is merely the postulations of men at the time, then surely the resurrection would have to go.  It has never happened before or since so it must be myth or falsehood, right?  If that is the case, then by Paul's own words we are a pitiful people.

Oddly enough, I recently read a liberal Bible scholar complain about those who pressed him on the historicity of Genesis "why do you think God cannot use myth?"  God can do anything, supposedly, even using myth to express truth (except that the truth is devoid of fact or history).  What is even more odd is the whole idea that God has the power to express timeless truth in myth, legend, and fabrication but He does not have the power to create all things from nothing.  Or so it seems.  God is so big that He cannot be limited by the simple categories of fact and fiction but He is not so big that He can speak all that is into being.  Go figure.

Either you refuse to believe Genesis because you have more faith in the postulations of modern science than you do Scripture or you refuse to believe Genesis because you do not believe Scripture is God's Word (but perhaps only contains snippets of it).  In either case, it is clear that you have approached the Scriptures with a doubting mind and heart.  Now the reality is that modernity is in love with doubt.  We are suspicious of those who have no doubts or who have rested their doubts upon the Scriptures and are satisfied.  We are enamored with those who doubt, whose empiricism requires a level of provable truth that removes all risk from believing.  Thomas is the patron saint of the doubters and the hero who alone is true to himself.  The rest of those who believe are duped or fools.  Consider the recent movie The Concave and the appeal of doubts as part of the necessary character of the man whom they would proclaim Pope.  Or look at the death of Francis and his legacy of doubts and challenges to what the faith has always confessed about such things as gender, marriage, children, abortion, homosexual acts, etc...  Francis is a hero to our times because he is not a true blue believer but always found room for doubts (who am I to judge).  In the world today, the best Christian is the one who doubts what the Bible says, the doctrine the faithful have confessed, the morality that has guided holiness of life and speech, and the Gospel of Christ crucified for sinners.  We call these people saints and scholars today but in reality they are little more than doubters who find more confidence in the best guesses of the time for what is and who believe the Gospel is little more than an idea that lives in our imagination rather than in history.  How odd!

Thursday, May 29, 2025

He ascended into heaven. . .

There was a day when this was a day -- an occasion for us to pause what we are doing and come together in the Lord's House on the fortieth day after Easter.  Now it is liable to be celebrated at a more convenient time on the following Sunday or perhaps not at all.  Strange it is how the Ascension of Our Lord has become merely a phrase in the creed and virtually disappeared from the important feasts of the Church's life and our worship.

Early Christians regarded the Feast of the Ascension as one of the major feasts of the Christian calendar.  It was up there with Easter and even ahead of Christmas. It was the culminations of the festal calendar of  those festivals celebrating the events of Christ’s life.  The ancient Christians celebrated the feast in part by walking -- what we call processing -- outside as Jesus did when He was taken up from the sight of His disciples.  Processions imitated Jesus’ journey with the disciples to the Mount of Olives remembering how He had opened the Scriptures to them and filled them with joy.  Their celebrated of the Feast of the Ascension was marked with great joy and not loss or disappointment or even uncertainty (Luke 24:52). Joy is not so much the character of Christians today.  In fact, it is probably one of the reasons why we do not celebrate His departure to the right hand of the Father with the joy that the disciples once felt as they returned to Jerusalem. 

Ascension proclaims that Jesus, who left heaven and came to earth incarnate in the womb of the Virgin Mary by the Holy Spirit, has completed all things appointed to Him and returns to heavenly glory as the victor.  He ascends to the Father with you and me still urgent in His heart and pleads for those for whom He died and rose again.  His presence is no more the visible presence of flesh and blood as a man walking among us but the flesh and blood of the Lord who now presides at and gives Himself to us in the Holy Eucharist.  The visible presence of the Lord on earth has paused, but He does not cease to be with His earthly people in His flesh and blood sharing with them His divine life and we will once again at the time He has appointed see Him face to face.  Now, He rules over all things, sitting at the right hand of the Father on high, from which He came to us on earth.  He is no spirit unbound from body but the incarnate Christ who forevermore lives in human flesh and blood even as He ascends to reign at God’s right hand.  He said He was going to prepare a place for us and so He has gone until that day when He will return in glory having put all our enemies, last of all death, under His feet.

He rules by bestowing the Spirit whom the Father sends in His name upon His disciples -- even you and me.  In the Pentecost miracle, His Spirit unleashed His witnesses to tell what He has done and by this same Spirit He still sends forth pastors to proclaim this eternal Gospel to the ends of the earth, bestowing upon those for whom He died and rose the gifts He won.  This is a feast for those outside the realm of His Church even as it is for those within as the forgiveness of sins is announced in His name across the world to every tribe and nation.  With that absolution and restoration comes the promise that we will ascend over every sin, death and even hell itself, that our death is not the end of us or a release from our bodily prison but our rest until a new flesh and blood are bestowed upon us so that we might enter into the new heavens and earth He prepares.

Once the Ascension was a mighty feast commanding an octave at least or even more so a mini season of Ascensiontide, from the fortieth day after His resurrection until the fiftieth when the Spirit is given.  Now, sadly, it is not even a real day.  The noble hymns of the Ascension are given lip service and the Paschal Candle just suddenly appears by the font as if it had been in the wrong place before.  Our liturgical gestures are lost without that moment when His ascension is read, the candle is extinguished, and the focus placed now upon the means of grace as the vehicles of His presence among us.  As Norman Nagel once said, if Jesus is everywhere then He is nowhere at all.  We do not live in some spiritual world where you just might bump into God but in the concrete world where God has promised to be where He has attached Himself.  Our Lord lives among us in the Word and Sacraments.  We apprehend Christ not by sight but by faith, trusting in His promises but most of all in His promise to be with us always even to the end of the age.

Wednesday, May 28, 2025

FREEDOM. . .

Who can forget the scene in the movie Braveheart when William Wallace (Mel Gibson) cries out "They can take our lives but they'll never take our FREEDOM!"  In tormented voice, he ends the movie with the same word, "Freedom!"  It was an iconic moment in 1995 and remains so.  It has been romanticized and revoiced into the 21st century ethos of gender choice, sexual desire, and ever other life defining decision that we want to make or insist upon making for ourselves.  But, alas, freedom is not the real mark of humanity or the most noble expression of our humanity.  There are others.  The quality of mercy is one.  What separates humans from animals is the choice to have mercy, forgiving, forgetting, restoring, and renewing ourselves and our lives together by refusing to take full advantage of freedom.  Self-denial is another.  The most profound freedom does not demand but willingly sacrifices of self for the sake of another -- be that other familiar or stranger.  The cost of love is often that very freedom.

There is another character to our humanity that is self-defining.  That is our refusal to live in the moment.  Yes, you heard me right.  The refusal to live so fully in the moment that we ignore all who came before and live oblivious to those who would follow us.  GK Chesterton said it "Tradition means giving votes to the most obscure of all classes, our ancestors. It is the democracy of the dead. Tradition refuses to submit to that arrogant oligarchy who merely happen to be walking around.."   Jaroslav Pelikan put it this way:  "Tradition is the living faith of the dead. Traditionalism is the dead faith of the living."  Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., had this to say:  "Science and technology revolutionize our lives, but memory, tradition and myth frame our response."  And then W. Somerset Maugham, "Tradition is a guide and not a jailer."

Your definition of yourself is hardly the bedrock of our humanity but our ability to remember, to recall, to honor that memory, to learn from it, and to pass it on.  That is humanity -- except where we have lost so much of our humanity that we no longer know who we are at all.  Dorothy Day accurately diagnoses the ills of modernity:  "Tradition! We scarcely know the word anymore. We are afraid to be either proud of our ancestors or ashamed of them. We scorn nobility in name and in fact. We cling to a bourgeois mediocrity which would make it appear we are all Americans, made in the image and likeness of George Washington."  None of us can go back but that does not mean we cannot look back into what was in order to better know today and prepare for the future.  The call to tradition is not to be custodians of ashes and cold coals but to tend to the very flame and fire that will warm our present and enlighten our future.
 
What we draw from our past is not the useless information that so dominates our present.  No, what we draw from the past is an appreciation for that information and framework in which to interpret and apply the facts and figures that can be reduced to mere numbers so that they speak in words.  In the same way, Christianity is nothing apart from the past but it is not a simple record of what was.  Its tense always speaks of that which has not only continuing significance but power to mark what is to come.  We confess the faith that is not a testimony of what was but of what is and what is to come because of what was.  If God is the One who was, who is, and who is to come, only the tradition of this God can possibly hope to open a door by which we can enter the future and carry with us the living legacy of those who went before us.  So we add our voices to those who went before, confessing the creed in ancient words that have present and future impact and praying with the saints to the God who is not encumbered by the crass division of past, present, and future.  
 
We are at our best as people when we live within that living tradition passed on to us to be passed down through us.  The voices that scream "Freedom!" are shrill and unpleasant because they would abandon the wisdom of our fathers for the foolish whims of the present or the untested plans of tomorrow.  Indeed, the only anchor in our human is tradition -- the living tradition of Christ and those who live in Him and therefore with Him forevermore.  The Gospel of Christianity is not the gift to define yourself without knowledge or credit to those who went before you and without regard for those who will come after, but to be defined by the ever-living Gospel of Christ and Him crucified.  In this Christianity there is no such thing as instant catechesis or quick holiness or spontaneous prayer.  For some this is a bad thing but for the wise this is the most comforting thing of all.  

God said it this way:  "Therefore, brethren, stand fast and hold the traditions which you were taught, whether by word or our epistle. Now may our Lord Jesus Christ Himself, and our God and Father, who has loved us and given us everlasting consolation and good hope by grace, comfort your hearts and establish you in every good word and work." (2Th 2:15-17)  "Those who leave the tradition of truth do not escape into something which we call Freedom. They only escape into something else, which we call Fashion." as Chesterton put it. 


Tuesday, May 27, 2025

The Bible does not say that. . .

For as long as Scripture has been there have been those who lived on its edges rather than deep in its words.  We have suffered mightily those who insist that absent an explicit word on this or that, the Scriptures could or should be taken differently than has been understood.  It is wearisome enough when this comes from those who are refusing the implication inherent in the Word but it is downright foolish when it comes from those who insist that they are only trying to let Scripture speak.

Take, for example, the oddity of a Christianity Today column which purports to say that the Bible never actually says that Jesus was nailed to the cross.  You can read for yourself:

The Bible doesn’t describe Jesus being nailed to a cross.

Telling the story of Christ’s death, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John simply say that Roman soldiers crucified him. They don’t say how. Each of the Gospels include specific detail about the soldiers’ method of dividing Jesus’ clothes—a lottery—but none describe the way the soldiers put him on the cross. There are no nails mentioned in any of the four accounts of Christ’s death.

How odd it is when doubts about the traditional understanding of anything in Scripture comes from sources which ordinarily could be counted upon to respect the conservative reading of the text.  You might expect anything and everything from the media or from the known suspects of a skeptical reading of the Bible but not from someone who teaches at an "evangelical" seminary.  

Jeffrey P. Arroyo García, an evangelical Bible scholar who teaches at Gordon College, thinks maybe there weren’t any nails.

“The word used there, stauroo, just means ‘to hang on a cross,’” García told Christianity Today. “But it doesn’t give the method of how they hang, right? Maybe the reticence is telling.”

In an effort to justify the lack of mention of the nails, someone who claims to be a Bible scholar seems to have forgotten that Thomas did not ask to see rope burns but the marks of the nail.  It is exactly this kind of omission that is too often the reason for getting it wrong about a lot of things.  Baptismal regeneration is not mentioned once but so strongly implied in many texts that it is foolish to argue against it.  The Real Presence of Christ's real flesh and blood in the real food of bread and wine is so implicit in everything that Scripture records and says of the Holy Eucharist that it is more telling about the deniers than it is what they deny here.  The creation of male and female and its constant weaving of this order throughout the Scriptures is so strong that it reveals a certain blindness to suggest that many genders does not conflict with what God has said.  The push toward the single life, divorce, same sex marriage, or an intentionally childless union searches in vain for Scriptural support and ignores the way marriage, children, and family are spoken of in Scripture.  The coexistence of evolution with the Biblical text has many defenders but it ignores how Jesus speaks of the creation and especially of Adam and Eve.  Rome condemning justification by grace through faith is another one of those can't see the forest for the trees kind of things that insists if something is not said explicitly it cannot be presumed (even when it is actually said pretty well in the Biblical text!).

I could go on.  It is mystifying how we insist upon Scripture being explicit in its reference before we will acknowledge what is so implicit in it.  Like Jesus being crucified with ropes instead of nails.  Wow.  Thankfully the author acknowledged this in a later version but it is the strangest thing that it happened in the first place.

 

Monday, May 26, 2025

In memoriam. . .

As we celebrate Memorial Day weekend, there will be congregations all over the US who will carry in the flag, have an honor guard, sing patriotic songs, and hear patriotic messages.  I suppose it could be worse but it does bother me that when we think of patriotism we think of hijacking Gospel for the sake of being good citizens.  Being good citizens is something good and if we do it right, we do not have to hide or skip the Gospel.

In times of threat when it seems the Gospel is being constrained and in moments of persecution when the Gospel is being threatened by restrictions and by those who label it hate speech, we do not need patriotic displays on Sunday morning to prove we are good citizens.  We need good citizenship Monday through Saturday.

On this day when we are mindful of our soldiers who made the ultimate sacrifice, it seems very little indeed for us to strive to be model citizens in respecting the rule of law, seeking to obey the laws (except where they conflict with Scripture), and praying for our nation and our leaders.  Good citizenship is not waving the flag on Sunday morning but living up to that flag Monday through Saturday.  This should be a no-brainer for Christians.  St. Paul has laid out some of the things we should be about when the Church was under threat and Christianity itself was not a legal religion.  Those of us who live where we are free to be Christian ought to use every opportunity this liberty provides to show forth what is good, right, beautiful, and honorable before the nation.

Praying for our leaders, praying for our nation, and praying for the fruitful exercise of liberty's gift is one of the hallmarks of our Christian identity.  Living to serve our neighbor in love is not an optional or occasional activity for Christian people -- it is our life.  Perhaps now more than ever, good citizenship is needed from those in the pew.  We will be misunderstood and we will be threatened by those who try to dilute or deny the truth of the cross and empty tomb . . . BUT we fight on various levels and not always with the mouth or the pen.  In fact, though God does not need any of our good works, our neighbor does and those good works may be some of the profound means by which we manifest the true nature of Christ and His Kingdom.

Growing up, this was a very important holiday.  I am still moved by Memorial Day, by the stark numbers of those long ago and only yesterday who paid the ultimate price to defend my freedom and protect my nation.  I am moved by the many ways in which we keep alive this cost of freedom and honor those who died to protect the American way of life.  I am moved by the memory of veterans making the slow walk to the casket of my father-in-law and saluting their brother in death.  I am moved by flag of my own father's service to his country and the veterans who honored him in death.  But the best way for the Christian to honor the sacrifices of those who died is not to turn the church into a patriotic hall of fame.  No, it is to compel us with the Word of God to be the good citizens we ought to be -- from the neighborhoods in which we live to the states that mark our greater borders.  Christians, be good citizens and the attacks of our enemies on Christianity will not stick.  We have more than a message of "no" to all that is wrong; we also have the good works of Him who called us from darkness into His marvelous light.