The moral of the story is this:
- Change Happens
- They Keep Moving The Cheese
- Anticipate Change
- Get Ready For The Cheese To Move
- Monitor Change
- Smell The Cheese Often So You Know When It Is Getting Old
- Adapt To Change Quickly
- The Quicker You Let Go Of Old Cheese, The Sooner You Can Enjoy New Cheese
- Move With The Cheese
- Enjoy Change!
- Savor The Adventure And Enjoy The Taste Of New Cheese!
- Be Ready To Change Quickly And Enjoy It Again
- They Keep Moving The Cheese.
In the name of moving the cheese, Lutherans have been urged to ditch the liturgy, skip the hymns of old, ignore their Confessions, dump vestments, rearrange the furniture in the sanctuary, and, in short, give up on those things that make them Lutheran. The goal is, of course, to win converts for Jesus and the enemy of that goal is everything that stands in the way of making those converts (like doctrine and practice). But then again, you know where I stand.
Let me put it another way. . . The Roman Catholic Church announced that five bishops are leaving the Church of England (Anglican) and becoming Roman Catholic. As one wag put it, Anglicanism and Rome were once fairly close together. Who moved? (Who moved the cheese?) Rome has stayed fairly consistent although Sunday morning looks different in Rome than it did in 1530. Anglicans don't look much at all like the people they used to be. Again, who moved?
The ELCA and Missouri are often framed as Lutherans on a different path (rightfully so) but the truth is that once the paths were very close together (Common Service, Galesburg rule, moral stance, etc.). Missouri is sometimes accused by the ELCA to having changed (and there is a bit of truth to it) but who really changed? (Who moved the cheese?)
Presbyterians were once thoroughgoing Calvinists and now it is hard to find a real Calvinist anywhere. Arminians have taken over the Church of Calvin and Knox. There are still the Heidelberg Catechism and the Confessions of Westminster and Dordt among others, but who pays all that much attention to them today. Who moved? (Who moved the cheese?)
I could continue but my point is this. What is the cheese in all of this? It appears as if the "cheese" is the doctrine and practice of these churches and that it is a movable object subject to shifts of interpretation and meaning which the theological heirs of these faiths are free to move or change as they feel necessary. I fear that the problem is not that somebody moved the cheese but we have been moving it around so much, we don't even know what the cheese is or why it is still important. Change has become the new fashionable god of politics, culture, and religion. The cheese is not important but the moving is -- change is object of our infatuation. We change doctrine, practice, morality, and truth because we like to change them and we want to change them. It has less to do with the desire to be effective or efficient as much as it has to do wanting to reinvent ourselves on a regular basis.
Who moved the cheese? It seems to me that the cheese does not move and the whole goal of Christianity is to stay close to the cheese. It seems to me that those churches who have moved the cheese are the very ones who have lost their Christian identity. Does a Joel Osteen bear much more resemblance to creedal orthodoxy than the Mormons? I don't know anymore. Does a church so enamored with the cusp of moral change bear much more resemblance to the classic Christian identity than Islam confesses Christ? I don't know anymore. Does a church which delights in breaking all the rules and tearing down the bridges that connect us to our Christian heritage (Tradition) bear any resemblance to the Church Jesus Christ said hell could not overcome? I don't know anymore. It seems to me that the rule we have forgotten is that the cheese never moves. We change and stay the same. The world changes and remains the same. The needs of people change and yet are consistent from age to age. The Church does not need to jump on the bandwagon of change but to offer the world a, well, to quote an old phrase from LCMS history, changeless Christ for a changing world.