Elizabeth Goodine as written a somewhat passionate but rather panicked response to the Becker situation. You can read it here. She ends with some hysteria equating the refusal of Dr. Becker to teach in accord with the publicly stated doctrine and to practice consistently with the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod as a modern day Nazi machine moving to rigidly enforce a false truth and to prevent truth, justice, reason, and the American way of tolerance and accommodation from winning the day.
There are a number of things Ms. Goodine forgets.
- Missouri is a church at rest doctrinally. It takes a lot to move something from its resting position. That is always the way it has been for Missouri. The issues in the Becker case are not new nor have they ever been but a very small minority opinion. Missouri is fully at ease with its conviction that Adam and Eve were historical people, that the Scriptural record is trustworthy and true (factually as well as spiritually), that the move to women's ordination was not a choice given to the church to make, and that close(d) communion was and is the faithful practice of the church through the ages. This is the DNA of Missouri. If change comes, it does not come through the front door but slips in the back door. Whenever Missouri has faced the question of changing its doctrinal stance, it has never failed to fall back on its yesterday, today, and, hopefully, forever position.
- Missouri is NOT a hierarchical church. While few do have some power to hold us accountable to what we said we believed and agreed to practice, we elect them regularly and they are fully accountable to lay and clergy votes. Synodical Presidents, the Praesidium, District Presidents, and Circuit Visitors are nominated and elected. Some sitting folks have been unelected and some have decided not to run again when they felt the direction the wind was blowing. Yes, it is true that the majority of DPs are re-elected but that does not mean that Missouri is the victim of a machine or a hierarchy out of sync with the pews and pulpits of our members.
- No one is going for anyone. Dr. Becker was not held accountable for private opinion or even for raising a question. He was and is an persuasive, erudite, and scholarly individual who has had every venue to make his points, win over his audience, and change the face of Missouri. The fact that he failed to do this has little or nothing to do with those elected on a Synodical or District level. It has everything to do with the fact that the positions he advocated represent a substantial shift in the thinking and practice of Missouri against Scripture and our Confessions as well as the particular issues themselves.
Justice is a good thing. Mercy is better. The LCMS has been painfully slow and very reluctant to hold people accountable and to act with fair and impartial consequences when they refuse to heed the counsel of their supervisors and teach and practice faithfully with respect to what we have said and agreed upon. That will not change. It may frustrate some who want swift action but it is the slow, deliberate path of love. Some have forgotten this and have spoken or acted rashly. I pray I am not one of them but I know when I hear rhetoric that is over the top. Points made in this regard are seldom helpful except at raising the level of heat and diminishing the light in such circumstances.