According to Archbishop Richard Moth of Westminster, president of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales, this is an important demonstration of closeness between the United Kingdom and the Holy See and symbol of the deep historical connections between the papacy and the English monarchy, obviously those which long predate the English Reformation. For Moth, this not simply diplomacy a sign of hope for future relations between Catholics and Anglicans, rooted in Christ’s prayer for his disciples “that they may all be one” (John 17:21).
It is sort of like the golden rose the pope sent to Frederick the Wise. A gesture. But it is, realistically, a hollow one. The Church of England is rapidly declining while the Roman Catholic Church there is on the increase. Indeed, by attendance alone it might be the largest church in England. But even more so, it comes from a king who has preferred to defend the idea of faith without its particular expression in creedal Christianity. He who has redefined his own role might be intent on redefining what it means to be Christian and to find accord where none really exists. On the other hand, Rome is gaining a church body which is ever so good at ceremony even though the words and actions seem to be without an accompanying belief in what they sign or say. Is that the future of Rome? Is that the path to the future Leo XIV envisions? It would seem that this raises as many questions as it seems to answer.
In any case, the time for fluff is long gone. Division and conflict will no more be solved with the announcement of an engagement or the bartering off of a daughter or a son. It is far too late for that. What needs to happen is no mere show of symbolic unity but the strength of the confession to meet and actually determine what the Scriptures say, what is the faith of the saints, and what we confess today. The hollow gestures of the past make for a great photo op but terrible ecclesiology. Rome does not need ecumenical partners intent upon destroying the doctrine of the faithful by indifference or by a smug sophistication which views dogma more as ignorance than reason under the tutelage of God's Word. Rome should come and sit down at the table with Missouri, small though Missouri might be, because here the faith is boldly confessed and Scripture taken seriously. It is a good show for popes to sit down with ecumenical leaders (especially female ones) but it does zero to effect any real good will or unity. The Church of England, along with nearly all of liberal Protestantism, will not be deterred from their path of progressivism by an exchange of titles or even a good bottle of scotch. I honestly do not get why this is important to either Rome or Canterbury. Rome surely does not mean to endorse the version of Christianity lite being played out in Canterbury and Canterbury does not mean to endorse the version of Christianity (minus the ordination or women or the embrace of all sexual desires and genders) which is set forth by Rome. So why do it? If ecumenism means anything, the partners need to get serious and find those who mean to be serious to be serious.




