According to the dictionary barbarism means:
I guess the meaning intended by the critics is not the third and perhaps not even the first but the second usage according to the dictionary. I suppose you could say that it is ignorant or crude to put to death those who have been found guilty of particularly heinous crimes. I presume that the intention of that word when used in conjunction with the death penalty is more that it is savage, violent, and cruel in a civilized, educated, and sophisticated time such as ours. Perhaps it is, to a certain degree, but I find it curious how easily that word is applied to the legitimate authority of the state to punish the evildoer but it is not used against many currently popular practices (abortion, euthanasia, etc.) and not even of the crimes these individuals were charged with and for which they were convicted. Apparently only those who think the death penalty may be imposed are barbarous while the criminals for whom it is to be used are not. How odd!
In 1995, when she was 18, Pike and her boyfriend lured their 19-year-old classmate Colleen Slemmer into a wooded area in Knoxville where they tortured and killed her. Slemmer was beaten, slashed, and had a pentagram carved in her chest before Pike killed her by crushing her skull. Pike was arrested within two days and sentenced to death in 1996. So her torture and murder of her classmate is not barbarism but the death penalty is? Nidal Hasan served as a United States Army major and perpetrated the 2009 Fort Hood shooting, in which he murdered 13 people and injured 32 others -- a crime to which he confessed at his court-martial in August 2013. Executing him is barbarous but not what he did? Okay.
Killing a conscious child in the womb at the whim of the mother and allowing this as a matter of law and women's reproductive health is not barbarous but suggesting that it ought to stop is. Taking a child from the parents and home over the parents refusal to administer hormone blocking drugs to a teen (or younger) who believes their body is the wrong gender is barbarism but acting on the whim of that child to permanently disfigure their body before they are even of legal age to buy a pack of cigarettes is not? Finding the drugs which make it possible for someone to die painlessly at their own decision whenever they decide life is too much is not barbarous but insisting there are no such drugs available to do the same for someone under a sentence of death is okay. Deciding to end the life of someone against their will or without their consent or ability to consent is not barbarism but carrying out a death sentence on someone who a court has found incapable of understanding what is being done to them is. Okay.
I just don't get it. Barbarism is something which legitimately characterizes some of the heinous crimes and immoral things our society has decided are okay but I find it hard to apply that term to the legitimate and lawful decision of a court and a jury that this person ought to be put to death for their crimes. It may not be wise or effective but the death penalty no matter how it is carried out is hardly as barbarous as the crimes that got those folks on death row. Can we at least agree to that? Perhaps the death penalty has outlived its usefulness. I do not know. I am no expert. But I really cannot fathom how the penalty duly assigned by a court of law in accord with the laws of the land is so routinely considered to be barbarism but their crimes are not. That is what I find inconsistent and, well, barbarism.




