Monday, November 16, 2026

Barbarism. . .

Living in Tennessee makes me particularly susceptible to the constant coverage of the mishandled execution of convicted murder Christa Pike -- a news cycle further enhanced by the addition of the furor over the execution and, at least for a time, livestreaming of it for Nidal Hasan for his crimes.  I do not know where you stand on the whole idea of capital punishment.   You could be Roman and have rewritten history and your catechism by papal fiat to say something the Roman Church did not say until very modern times.  You could be militant and wonder why it took Tennessee 30 years and the Army 17 to get around to fulfilling the verdict once given.  You could be like me, one who supports the idea the death penalty as Scriptural and legitimately within the realm of the state even as he wonders if its purpose has been overcome by the increasing length of time between sentence and it being carried out and a host of other things.  In any case, my concern here is the word barbarism as applied to the death penalty overall and to the mishandling of the Pike execution and the, for a time anyway, idea of publicly livestreaming Nasan's.

According to the dictionary barbarism means:

  • The condition of having no civilizing influences or refined culture; ignorance or crudity.
  • Savage violence or cruelty.
  • The use of words, forms, or expressions considered incorrect or unacceptable. 
  • I guess the meaning intended by the critics is not the third and perhaps not even the first but the second usage according to the dictionary.  I suppose you could say that it is ignorant or crude to put to death those who have been found guilty of particularly heinous crimes.  I presume that the intention of that word when used in conjunction with the death penalty is more that it is savage, violent, and cruel in a civilized, educated, and sophisticated time such as ours.  Perhaps it is, to a certain degree, but I find it curious how easily that word is applied to the legitimate authority of the state to punish the evildoer but it is not used against many currently popular practices (abortion, euthanasia, etc.) and not even of the crimes these individuals were charged with and for which they were convicted.  Apparently only those who think the death penalty may be imposed are barbarous while the criminals for whom it is to be used are not.  How odd!

     In 1995, when she was 18, Pike and her boyfriend lured their 19-year-old classmate Colleen Slemmer into a wooded area in Knoxville where they tortured and killed her. Slemmer was beaten, slashed, and had a pentagram carved in her chest before Pike killed her by crushing her skull. Pike was arrested within two days and sentenced to death in 1996.  So her torture and murder of her classmate is not barbarism but the death penalty is?  Nidal Hasan served as a United States Army major and perpetrated the 2009 Fort Hood shooting, in which he murdered 13 people and injured 32 others -- a crime to which he confessed at his court-martial in August 2013.  Executing him is barbarous but not what he did?  Okay.

    Killing a conscious child in the womb at the whim of the mother and allowing this as a matter of law and women's reproductive health is not barbarous but suggesting that it ought to stop is.  Taking a child from the parents and home over the parents refusal to administer hormone blocking drugs to a teen (or younger) who believes their body is the wrong gender is barbarism but acting on the whim of that child to permanently disfigure their body before they are even of legal age to buy a pack of cigarettes is  not?  Finding the drugs which make it possible for someone to die painlessly at their own decision whenever they decide life is too much is not barbarous but insisting there are no such drugs available to do the same for someone under a sentence of death is okay.  Deciding to end the life of someone against their will or without their consent or ability to consent is not barbarism but carrying out a death sentence on someone who a court has found incapable of understanding what is being done to them is.  Okay.   

    I just don't get it.  Barbarism is something which legitimately characterizes some of the heinous crimes and immoral things our society has decided are okay but I find it hard to apply that term to the legitimate and lawful decision of a court and a jury that this person ought to be put to death for their crimes.  It may not be wise or effective but the death penalty no matter how it is carried out is hardly as barbarous as the crimes that got those folks on death row.  Can we at least agree to that?  Perhaps the death penalty has outlived its usefulness.  I do not know.  I am no expert.  But I really cannot fathom how the penalty duly assigned by a court of law in accord with the laws of the land is so routinely considered to be barbarism but their crimes are not.  That is what I find inconsistent and, well, barbarism.   

     

    Sunday, November 15, 2026

    An interesting Reformation side. . .

    While some question the need for the Reformation then or its continuing relevance today, there is a strange debate going on in Rome that would seem to cry out for some Reformation help.  One is the way that Pope Francis seemed to decide for Roman Catholics that Scripture is wrong and the long history of the Church's tolerance of even if not endorsement of capital punishment is to no effect.  The pope changed the catechism and said the death penalty must be condemned.  This is hardly about the death penalty but about a growing debate within Rome over papal authority to decide something about which Scripture has already spoken clearly and then to go against the wisdom of God's Word.

    The issue is not so much about the death penalty itself but whether or not authentic development of doctrine in Rome can also then involve the very negation of explicit prior doctrine?  In other words, if God's Word has spoken and the Church given witness in its doctrine of the truth of something, can it later be changed or abrogated and if so does that mean it was wrong?  With it goes the parallel question of which doctrines are allowed to be changed and which cannot be changed, which belong to the deposit of the faith once for all delivered to the saints?

    It would seem that some are pretty intent about insisting that if the negated doctrine belongs to the deposit of faith, it cannot be abrogated nor set aside.  Can it be changed even by nuance?  Well, who knows?  Papal authority has been used to change many things, to invent things that never were either clearly nor uniformly said before, or to add to the deposit of faith.  So where does the death penalty stand?  I suppose that might interest some more than others but my question is deeper.  What are the limits of papal invention or doctrinal development?  This is a Reformation question to be sure. 

    As we approach Christ the King, the question of the state's acknowledgement of Christ's reign and rule come into play.  One pope invented a feast to draw attention to that but Vatican II seems oblivious at best to the whole idea.  Murder is always immoral.  Not because a pope concurs but because the law of God insists.  Is the death penalty murder?  In the past it was clearly a "no" but now it would seem that the direct, voluntary killing of an innocent human being is "always gravely immoral" and that the death penalty fits under this prohibition.  Who gets to definitively say so in this?  And what is this thing called human dignity.  Under Francis and Leo, the rule that would bar the death penalty is based not upon the Scriptures or any doctrine explicitly defined by Scripture but the surmising of such rule within the concept of "human dignity."  If they are wrong, who gets to say so?  

    Implicit in this is then the question of whether or not one may disagree with the pope in this and remain in good standing with the Roman Catholic Church?  When the pope invents a new position or new teaching, can you hold to the older teaching or is that prohibited and is it required by submission to accept what the pope decrees?  This seems to be again a Reformation question.  If Luther were here today, he would probably have something to say about it.  Along with some of the other rather colorful things he might say, I am fairly certain he would ask whether our allegiance is to the teaching of the church or its leaders OR to the Scriptures and the catholic faith?  The whole point of Lutheranism in the Augsburg Confession is that our submission in mind and will is not to a magisterium or a pope but to the Word of God.  That may not exactly be the cleanest thing to deal within practice but it is no less messy than popes who suddenly rise up to say, in effect, the Scriptures are wrong. 

    Saturday, November 14, 2026

    Real photos. . .

    There was a day when, if you asked a man about his family, he reached into a back pocket to pull out a worn wallet filled with worn but cherished printed photographs of his wife, children, parents, grandchildren, and maybe a few others.  Nowadays you pull out your phone and it lights up with the most brilliant of colors and the most realistic light to give you a vivid image of the man's whole family.  They are not worn or wrinkled or faded like the pictures printed on paper but as realistic and vibrant as our screens can render them.  But they are less real than the paper photographs.  It does not take but a moment to lose all those cherished photos and they are gone.  Literally.  It is harder to dispose of the paper kind.

    My grandchildren have, through the aid of digital creation, more photos of them in their few years than I have had in my many years.  But due to the age I am, more of mine were taken on a camera and printed on paper and not subject to cloud storage.  In my office at home I have a large cardboard box of photos given me by my brother from the drawers and nooks and crannies of my parents home.  He has already gleaned through them to keep what he wants and now he has given me the same opportunity.  I have already looked through them a couple of times.  They are storied journeys through my past and through the past of my family.  There are many folks in those photos who have been dead and gone for many years and, I confess, many whose names I no longer recall -- even if their faces are familiar.  They are real.  I will eventually dispose of them but for now I keep them and in keeping them am keeping their subjects alive -- at least within my own mind.

    I have to admit that I am not sure what to think of our digital realities.  They do not collect dust in old cardboard boxes but neither do they exist outside the screens on which they live when we turn them on and scroll down to them.  That is not an improvement, I think.  Our lives are fragile enough without consigning them to an off button or a delete button.  The screens only amplify how transient and fragile our lives have become through the aid of our technology.  Improvement?  Not in my mind.  The paper prints may fade or wrinkle or fold but they are real in a way that the digital stuff is not.  And not only photos.

    Sadly, the practice today is to either omit or make as brief and nondescript as possible obituaries.  It is as if we are in a rush to erase the lives of those who lived.  As bad as that is, I absolutely hate the practice of disposing of ashes by casting them into the wind or sea of the favorite spots of the person whose body was once more than ashes or dust.  It is as if they never existed.  Then, without a tombstone, we go it even further by leaving them without any sort of permanent resting place.  The burials at sea and such in the past were done not as best practice but as something born of necessity, a compromise at best.  Now we are no longer compromising.  We are choosing to eliminate the casket and burial and gravestone by throwing into the wind all the earthly remains of our loved ones.  Is it an improvement?  Cheap, yes, and easy, but better?  I certainly do not wish to line the pockets of the funeral industry and decry what that has become with a charge for every service that makes it necessary to take a second mortgage to take care of the remains of your loved ones.  There must be a better way than a $15-20,000 funeral and burial package complete with $1500 of flowers to show the world how much the one dead was loved.  But choosing to live with a means of dealing with the dead that casts them to the wind is not the solution.  Perhaps next we will all be born with a delete button to take care of all the loose ends when we want to check out or our loved ones want to be done with us.  I hate it.  Give me a body, casket, wake, church funeral, and burial any day of the week.  And real photos.  Not just a screen where you have to wait for the brief blip of an image until it fades into another -- all before you have had a chance to really look at it.  Real photos, too.

    I could say the same for screens on church walls instead of hymnals, websites with newsletter sections instead of printed newsletters, and QR codes for seemingly everything.  We can tell ourselves all day long that such things are real but as soon as you turn them off, delete them, or stop paying for the cloud storage, they are gone.  How sad!  

    Friday, November 13, 2026

    I will with the help of God. . .

    Every form of baptismal liturgy includes the promises or vows made either by the one being baptized or on behalf of the baptized by parents and sponsors.  They normally revolve around the devil, his works, and his ways -- renouncing them because the baptized now belongs to the Lord.  With those renunciations comes the promises of faith.  Do you believe in God the Father, do you believe in Jesus Christ His Son, and do you believe in the Holy Spirit.?  They mirror the three articles of the Apostles Creed.  Finally is the simple question of whether the candidate wishes to be baptized.  While it may have been the temptation of other ages to add to these, until more recently most have not succumbed to that desire.  At least among the Lutherans this is so.

    In the Baptismal Covenant in the 1979 Book of Common Prayer, these questions were reformulated as follows:

    Question    Do you renounce Satan and all the spiritual forces of wickedness that rebel against God?
    Answer    I renounce them.

    Question    Do you renounce the evil powers of this world  which corrupt and destroy the creatures of God?
    Answer    I renounce them.

    Question    Do you renounce all sinful desires that draw you from the love of God?
    Answer    I renounce them.

    Question    Do you turn to Jesus Christ and accept him as your Savior?
    Answer    I do.

    Question    Do you put your whole trust in his grace and love?
    Answer    I do.

    Question     Do you promise to follow and obey him as your Lord?
    Answer    I do. 

    I am not sure I find these an improvement.  Certainly the idea of turning to Jesus Christ and accepting Him as your Savior is borrowing too much from evangelicalism and decision theology and is an invention that harms more than helps.  I suppose the promise to put your whole trust in His grace and love is innocuous enough but it is also vague enough as to allow just about anyone to say yes.  The promise to follow and obey Him as Lord ordinarily belongs in confirmation or the promises of an adult or older child being received into membership in the congregation and even then borrow too much from evangelicalism and decision theology as to draw attention away from what God is doing here and to the candidate.

    Then follows a couple more questions which, while not bad and certainly sounding Scriptural, are rather out of place:

    Celebrant     Will you continue in the apostles' teaching and fellowship, in the breaking of the bread, and in the prayers?
    People     I will, with God's help.
     
    Celebrant     Will you persevere in resisting evil, and, whenever you fall into sin, repent and return to the Lord?
    People     I will, with God's help.

    The content of the questions and adding to what has traditionally been rather concise itself turns the focus away from what God is doing and what the candidate is to do or promises to do.  That is unhelpful, to say the least.  Then a couple of more questions are added to make this part of the rite longer than any other part.  That is certainly a problem.

    Celebrant     Will you proclaim by word and example the Good News of God in Christ?
    People     I will, with God's help.
     
    Celebrant     Will you seek and serve Christ in all persons, loving your neighbor as yourself?
    People     I will, with God's help.
     
    Celebrant     Will you strive for justice and peace among all people, and respect the dignity of every human being?
    People     I will, with God's help.

    The final question has a rather profound social justice bent to it and is also rather vague.  What exactly does it mean to strive for justice and peace among all people?  For an infant or child being baptized, in particular?  What does it mean to respect the dignity of every human being?  That is perhaps the broadest of terms and no one seems to know exactly what it implies.  Roman Catholics are always talking about human dignity without really saying anything about what that means.  I rather dislike those general terms and particularly dislike them added to the very specific act of God in baptizing a child to be His own.

    Even that, if you can believe it, is not enough.  Now another promise is being added by the Episcopalians.  This promise being tried in some congregations at the behest of the national church is concerned about the role of the baptized to “sustain and renew the life of the earth”.  A couple of years ago the Episcopal Church’s General Convention passed a resolution two years ago directing that the development of new language “that expresses our baptismal responsibility to care for creation”. It invited congregations to experiment with adding in a sixth promise, if their bishop gave permission.  In the diocese of Chicago, congregations can choose between two different version of a sixth promise: either “Will you strive to safeguard the integrity of God’s creation, and respect, sustain and renew the life of the Earth?” or “Will you cherish the wondrous works of God, and protect [or protect and restore] the beauty and integrity of all creation?”  While noble and certainly not wrong, do they belong in the baptismal rite?  This rite needs to focus on what God is doing and not on what we think we are called to do and certainly not upon our promises as if they have anything to do with God's action in baptism.  Our attempts to make things more relevant actually tends to make them less, tying them to specific cultural and political movements of the day while diluting the focus on what God is doing.   At least that is what I think.

    Thursday, November 12, 2026

    A funny bone. . .

    As I have written before, to me relics are a strange curiosity at best and an embarrassment to Christianity at worst.  In Lutheran history, the vast collection of relics by Frederick the Wise turned from something to be proud of into a foolish waste of funds.  I am sure that I read somewhere what he ended up doing with the odd collection but it did not end up being displayed for the faithful to earn merits by their devotion -- that is for sure.  But what a Lutheran ended up regretting remains a source of pride and a treasure for Rome.  Why?

    I recently read somewhere that Rome boasts a bone from the index finger of St Thomas the Apostle is located here. It is said that this is the same finger that he inserted into the side of the Risen Christ.   Indeed, there is an almost complete skeleton of him!  Tradition has it that Saint Thomas was buried in India until the 3rd century when his bones were dug up and transported to Edessa in Mesopotamia.  A thousand years later his bones were 'rescued' together with the tombstone to be taken to Italy (to remove this treasure from the threatening Turks).  They were apparently stolen while vacationing on the island of Chios in the Aegean and taken to Ortona in Italy.  There most of the bones were kept in the basilica San Thomasso Apostolo but the Turks desecrated them 300 years later.  From the 17th century to the present, the shrine has been opened several times for surveys of the bones and research.  Minus a few arm bones and above mentioned finger bone, there are bits and pieces a few other places.  It would seem that the bones of St. Thomas have had a rather storied career and we know more about that than we actually do the life of the apostles after famously being asked to touch the wounds of the risen Savior.

    What does this do for us today?  I am not sure that it helps the case for Jesus nor encourages faith in any doubters.  It makes for a good story but I wonder if there will ever be a time when the bones of the poor man can be laid to rest.  I doubt it.  Much as I love the stories of the lives of the saints, I find the business of relics to be odd and somewhat creepy.  Maybe it is simply my own Lutheran skepticism.  Maybe I am a victim of my own education to have doubts about the bones of the great doubter.  Maybe I fear what someone could do to my own bones that might end up dragging me around for a couple of thousand years.  Or maybe my concern is that all of this, interesting as it might be, detracts from rather than points to Christ.  It also seems to build on the very thing which St. Thomas thought he needed -- a little something to bolster the claim and make faith easier.  But can that be done?  Is is possible to make faith easier?  I doubt it.  Faith is faith.  Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.  The only thing which aids and assists the doubter are the things provided for us by Christ.  The Word which gives assurance of the things into which we have been catechized and the Sacraments which convey the very gifts His Word speaks and promises.  At some point, maybe we should let the bones lie, read the Word, and rejoice in the Sacraments.  Maybe then we will all find the assurance St. Thomas was looking for and of which his bones offer no promise.