Wednesday, August 6, 2025

Thoughts on building for worship. . .

The term sacred architecture does not immediately translate into a single form but it is not without its ideas.  Who among us has not winced at a church that was clearly built without worship in mind and who has not stood in awe of a structure that was clearly constructed to know and fulfill its purpose?  What is it that makes architecture sacred?

It helps if the architect and building committee are on the same page and fully understand what the purpose of the building is to be.  Yes, everyone knows about building codes and toilets, heating and air conditioning, cost and long term maintenance.  But the first place to begin is with the liturgy.  Preaching is important, music is important, acoustics to preserve both are important,, but as a liturgical space the focus is centered upon the altar.  The whole idea that worship is but one function of a multi-purpose space may work in concept but not in reality.  The gathering of God's people around His Word and altar is central and you know right away when somebody forgot that and built an auditorium or gym that now fails to fit what the Church does in that space.

Too often, the architect and building committee begin with the exterior.  This is not where you start but where you end.  The interior and the working of that space for the liturgical purpose of God's gathered people is always first.  We focus from the altar and back again.  Preaching is also central but the pulpit is a piece of furniture for the benefit of the preacher and the eye of the people and not what defines the worship space.  Everything flows out of the altar and back to it.  Circular buildings are imaginative but cost the worshiper the vital perspective so necessary for a liturgical church and a liturgical assembly.  Add to this the false idea that everyone needs to be close to the action in order for the building to "work."  If anything, the space should welcome people with a sense of the sacred and less as a vantage point to see something happen.  The expanse of the space needs to be vertical more than horizontal and it should lift the eye and the soul up to the heavens.  Yes, it is not cheap to built vertically but squatty churches fail almost from the get go.  They keep the focus down low and do not lift the worshiper to heaven.  This space needs to be proportionate to size but it needs to reach upward in little chapels as well as mighty cathedrals.  Yes, it is just air space but it may be the most important space in the entire building.

It is so sad when the volume of a structure is prevented.  How many times does a chancel feel like a forgotten closet added at the end rather than an expansive and important space for everyone?  How many times do we skip on the space where the altar and cross bring us together and there is no room left for the effective functioning of the liturgy, especially distribution?  How often does a Christmas tree steal the valuable real estate that belongs to the ministers and leaves them strangers to the very place where they serve God's people with God's gifts? 

How sad it is when the architect views the church as a his creation or the building committee sees the building in terms of cost effectiveness and then allows either or both of these to rob the churches of a structure that actually supports what happens on Sunday morning!  Both architect and building committee need to start by looking around and talking about what makes this building effective and that building disappointing.  Both architect and building committee need to study the liturgy and actually watch what happens on Sunday morning so that both know clearly and well the shape of the task before them.  We building our buildings and then they define us (Winston Churchill).  We want the legacy of our building to be a positive one.  Of course, there are always compromises and costs to be considered but building a cheap building that does not serve well its liturgical purpose will never be a wise or prudent stewardship decision.

Tuesday, August 5, 2025

The Dark Ages. . .

Later scholars biased toward the glories of ancient Rome coined the term the “Dark Ages” but were they really dark and was the Church to blame for the failings of the times?  Following 476 AD, the Germanic tribes conquered the western half of the Roman Empire and there was chaos in the aftermath.  Rome's legendary buildings and roads and infrastructure lay in decline but was this period stagnant or did it revert to an uncivilized and uneducated era?  In the aftermath of Rome's decline, the Church arose as the most powerful force in Europe, in effect defining what church and state would look like going forward.

Europe in the Early Middle Ages was without an empire or kingdom or political structure to unite its diversity and create a cohesive society.  Into this vacuum, the medieval Church grew into the most powerful institution in Europe, rising to its most influential point in the High Middle Ages (1000-1300 AD).

The strong papacy of Gregory the Great (pope from 590 to 604) gave boundaries and limits to the monarchs across Europe.  Monasticism had a profound influence upon the structures of church and state as well as later Western values and attitudes.  These monastic communities were havens of literacy and learning, patrons of the arts and artisans themselves, and actively encouraging charity and good works.  They also encouraged a work ethic, as Benedictines insisted that “Idleness is the enemy of the soul.”  The Early Middle Ages saw real and effective gains in the agriculture economy and production.  By the 10th century implements and mechanization were creating a bread basket where there had been little effective agricultural production before.

Great advances were made in science and math—in the Islamic world as well as in Christendom.  The myth that science and math were suppressed has labeled this period falsely as anti-learning.  The reality is that the foundations for the future advances were laid here during the "dark ages."  Unlike the Islam of today with its almost knee jerk reaction against progress,the Islamic world was also advancing in mathematics and the sciences.  Indeed the ninth-century Persian astronomer and mathematician al-Khwarizmi (c. 780-c. 850), introduced Europe to algebra and the Latinized version of al-Khwarizmi’s name gave us the word “algorithm.”  The Carolingian Renaissance period saw a real flowering of the arts, literature, and architecture as well.  

The 29 year old Karl, a son of Pepin the Short,  assumed complete control of the Frankish kingdom and reigned as Charlemagne (or Charles the Great) successfully defeating the Muslims in Spain, Bavarians and Saxons in northern Germany and Lombards in Italy.  In 800, Pope Leo III crowned Charlemagne “emperor of the Romans” (Holy Roman Emperor) and the crown and miter worked together to spread the faith.  During this time there was a rebirth of Roman-style architecture, educational reform, and the preservation of classic Latin texts.  By the time the Carolingian dynasty faded away the end of the ninth century (Charlemagne died in 814), the foundation for the future Renaissance had already been laid.

In reality, the Church preserved, rebuilt, and carried Western civilization forward while the world around it was falling apart.  While it did so in a way not possible today, as we face the end of eras and epochs and the transition of what was into what will be, the Church can also be one of the most stabilizing forces, assuring the passing on of the legacy of learning within the values and virtues of a distinctly Christian worldview in order to prevent chaos and disorder as well as provide a foundation for future rebirth and renewal.  Then, as now, the darkness may be exaggerated and the leadership of the Church may be resisted and yet who else will rise up with calm and hope for tomorrow?  Every generation insists the future is going to hell in a hand basket and they may be correct.  Yet God has placed us in our own times as leaven for the whole lump.  We will not accomplish anything good or lasting by hiding nor will we have any hope to offer unless that hope is clearly expressed within the context of God's grace and mercy and within the story of Christ crucified and risen.  When the fabric is being torn asunder, now is the time to take up the needle and thread and repair it, making it better than it was before, and assuring those that Gods' mercy is still our cover, the righteousness of Christ our clothing, and hope is not a myth.  Without monasteries to guide us, the local parish and our larger network of associations founded on those congregations will need to fill in the gap and take up the roles as leaders for our times.  

Monday, August 4, 2025

Is online the future?

In May of 2022, Gordon-Conwell Seminary announced that it was selling its main campus on the North Shore of Boston and switch to an online presence.  A little over a year later, they had changed their mind and sold housing units but not the seminary campus.  In the ELCA, Luther Seminary in St. Paul, Minnesota, has sold now all of its campus after having sold part of it earlier.  After 100 years in the St. Anthony Park neighborhood, the school will become an online presence.  The LCMS is replete with online schools with some residential presence who want to service its congregations (they seem to be popping up daily!) and has a very limited online program through its residential seminaries serving the SMP Pastor program.  There is a drumbeat to do something to create an online route to general ordination although the seminaries and conventions of the Synod have resisted an official path.  It is highly unlikely that any of the competitors will become a semi-official school of the Synod but that has not stopped those who think the "gold standard" of residential seminary education has lost its luster.

So who is right and who is wrong about the future?  Is Gordon-Conwell the smart bet or Luther?  Which seminary is better situated to serve its churches best and provide the best pastors?  It is a big bet.  Once you sell a property or close down a residential route in favor of an online presence, there are a great many hurdles to going back.  Are we in the LCMS prepared to bet the farm that what we see in the future is the only future for us?  I for one would not want to cover such a bet.  If we had long ago decided to merge our two seminaries, where would we have been in 1974?  Then, a generation later, it seemed that Concordia Seminary, St. Louis, just might innovate itself from the center to the fringe in Missouri and now that same Seminary is slowing down that side of things in order to consolidate and grow in tune with the Synod.  It is perhaps no secret that its former President, Dale Meyer, has signed on to the faculty of one of those upstarts trying to beat Missouri at its own game (along with one or two other former faculty).  Who has their ear to the ground and their eye on the future?  That is the million dollar question.

Apart from everything else, the question at the core is whether or not an online program can produce a better pastor for the churches than a residential seminary.  No one in their right mind would dispute they can do it more cheaply and faster but are cost and speed that which defines success?  Everyone knows that Missouri has a sentimental attachment to the campus that will soon celebrate its 100th anniversary but we all know it is not an inexpensive piece of real estate to maintain.  Everyone knows that the Ft. Wayne campus was the dream of the future until the future dried up the feeder schools and the big numbers of pre-sem students and then the Synod reinvented the campus as a seminary.  It is newer but in better shape and less costly to maintain.  One seminary has a $200+ million dollar endowment and the other a little less than half.  What would happen to the money that makes tuition largely free at both campuses?  How would we evaluate the readiness of the online candidates to serve our ministerium without knowing them face to face for more than weeks at a time?  We are barely recovering from the time when we knew the pre-seminary students for at least 8 and before than 12 years before laying hands on them.  How would we make the big shift from four years to a year's worth of weeks spread over even more years?

My point is simple.  Unless we are absolutely sure that this is the best path and the wisest path before us, we need to slow things down.  It sings great to run where the brave dare not go but it may not be the smartest thing to do.  The future is a mine field more than a racing track.  Success is defined less by speed than faithfulness and less by cost-effectiveness than what is good, right, and salutary.  As one of those in the midst of the transition from high school starting gates to ordination to college, I know how hard it is to recover from changes made too quickly.  The loss of Concordia Senior College and its feeder system through the Concordias (plus St. Paul's and St. John's) was hard to swallow and we are still digesting some of the after effects nearly 30 years later.  The loss of one or both seminaries in favor of an online option (probably impossible to prevent from being the primary path) would be even more difficult to process.  My plea to the Synod is to slow down.  The race between the tortoise and the hare is not a Biblical one but it can remind us that what seems a nobrainer now could leave us on life-support later.  Maybe we ought to read Proverbs 21:5 a few times before voting on something that is a stab into the darkness.  Steady plodding brings prosperity; hasty speculation brings poverty.

Sunday, August 3, 2025

Fullness. . .

As I have in the past, I continue to question and even to mock those who settle for less than fullness.  When it comes to liturgy, this is the attitude that one should not go overboard on anything -- from liturgy to the frequency of reception of the Sacrament to the ceremonial of the liturgy to the belief in the Real Presence.  All things in moderation has become somewhat the byword of our times and Lutherans are certainly not immune from the disease.  Of course, this is also true of the moderation of belief and the fear of the zealot who truly believes or believes truly what the Scriptures say.  Everyone knows that zealotry makes everyone nervous.  The fact that few prophets are the subject of stoning seems to confirm the fact that we have few prophets today.  It is much easier to sit in the middle than on the edge.

What is of equal consternation is the inexplicable desire to be moderate in holiness as well.  We seem content with a piety that is at best lukewarm.  I recently was asked by a layman if divorce would still prevent someone from serving as a pastor.  No, the sad truth is, divorce has become as ordinary in the Church as in the world and even on both sides of the altar rail.  There is not even a credible concern for an innocent party in all of this.  Things happen.  There was a time when divorce for any reason, whether you were the innocent or guilty party, was itself cause for removal from the roster.  Maybe that was patently unfair but it was clear.  The more you try to nuance things, the more difficult it is to hold toward marriage to one woman.  I well recall the first time I encountered an active Lutheran pastor who was married to a woman not of the Lutheran faith.  It was shocking to me not because I could not conceive of it happening but because I could not imagine how it would work to continue.  In one case, the Lutheran pastor was not even allowed to stand with his Roman Catholic wife for the baptism of their child.  That probably could not happen today but it is more because Roman has loosened up than Lutherans have tightened up their rules.  

Christianity, in contrast to the world, does not speak of minimums or medians but always of a “fullness.”  We do not find a muddling middle for piety or holiness or good works (even though good works do not purchase our salvation).  We are always striving for more than we will accomplish and this is particularly true of holiness.  We have an extravagant God.  He gives not what He must or what He can get away with but more than either deserve or dare ask.  He is foolishly extravagant and generous -- at least in our earthly eyes.  In His fullness He has acted for our salvation.  Even when He does not demand what is His right or His due, it is because He is acting as servant to a people who should be His servants.  He is incarnate of the Virgin Mary by the Holy Spirit not as a piece of God but as God in whom the fullness dwells.  He empties Himself not by slight of hand but into the cold darkness of our death -- fully embracing the cost of our salvation.  He rises not for Himself but to bestow upon us the fullness of what He has won and to prefigure for us our own resurrection and ascension into glory.  Until then, He does not watch from a distance or look for what we do but does what we cannot and gives what we need through the means of grace.  He daily and richly forgives our sins and "of His fullness we have all received, and grace for grace” (John. 1:16).  

The fullness is not something He demands as condition of our salvation or as the price of our entry into His divine life but as gift, grace, and goodness to sinners who never have and never will merit any of the fullness He gives.  Our striving for fullness is not in response to a command from His lips or a demand in exchange for His mercy but because He has given us all things.  That is why the line between sacred and secular is so foolish -- nothing is secular in Him.  Everything is held together by the glue of His merciful power and He lives to fill every aspect of daily life.  Islam can talk about the places where God is not but not the Christian.  Yes, hell is such a place but we do not know what it means except to know well and good it is not for us.  But faith is never running from something.  It is always running to -- to His grace upon grace, His mercy without end, and His fullness.  We do not forgive because the erring person earns it or a second chance.  We forgive because he forgave us.  We do not love because love is wonderful or romantic or rewarding.  We love because He first loved us.  We do not give because people notice or people are in need.  We give because He has given to us, pressed down, shaken, and overflowing.  We do not seek holiness to be His equal but because He embraced our sin so that we might begin to strive to be like Him in holiness of heart as well as life -- be holy because I am holy.  Once we begin settling for what is easy or find a comfort level in where we are, we are vulnerable.  The pride that goes before a fall is not some heavenly pitfall to punish us but living so comfortably in our emptiness that we no longer want or seek the fullness.  Don't settle.  Even if it means constant failure.  Don't settle.  His fullness continues not simply to forgive but to restore us that we might strive again.  His fullness fills us so that we might be filled.  In Word and Sacrament, He comes to the empty but will never leave them as they were.  

Saturday, August 2, 2025

Good News

On July 18, 2025, nine days before it was to have taken effect, a federal court blocked a Washington state law that would have penalized priests and pastors for refusing to report abuse disclosed during private confession/  In a press release from Becket, one of the legal groups representing the plaintiffs, the report chronicled the work to press back against the measure, signed into law by Gov. Jay Inslee on May 4, would have made Washington the first state in the country to explicitly remove legal protections for the seal of the confessional in abuse-related cases, and, in what could have been expanded, to other areas as well. The state scheduled enforcement of the law was to begin July 27 and will now be rendered null and void. 

The plaintiffs in the case — Archbishop Paul D. Etienne of Seattle, Bishop Joseph J. Tyson of Yakima, and Bishop Thomas A. Daly of Spokane — challenged the measure, with support from WilmerHale, Becket, and First Liberty Institute.  Although I do not know of any, one might have hoped for an amicus brief from somebody in the LCMS.  We also have a vested interest in the protection of the age old seal of the confessional.  The bishops argued the statute infringed on First Amendment rights and treated clergy unequally by stripping their confidentiality protections while preserving them for other professions, such as attorneys and counselors.  The blocked law would have imposed up to 364 days in jail, a $5,000 fine, and civil penalties on clergy found guilty of failing to report.  While everyone knew the feds were concerned about this overreach, the mere fact that the measure passed, was signed by the governor, and had some popular support illustrates the state of affairs between church and society in America.  It also illustrates how beholden churches are to those groups who have the funds and expertise to rise up against such violations of the religious freedom of Americans.

Friday, August 1, 2025

It's just a building. . .

For a very long time we have accepted as truth the idea that the first Christians did not have an idea of sacred space, that multi-purpose space was the norm, and that the nature of what happened in the liturgy and what happened at a family meal were more similar than distinct.  The myth has given birth to a liturgical theology and an architecture which has predominated in modern times and it has entrenched itself so deeply that nearly every ecclesiastical ideology accepts it.  Simple is not merely a preference for the eye or the ear but that which was from the beginning until an alien view of space and function corrupted the earlier pristine work.

Nowhere is this more practiced than with the use of church buildings no longer needed or wanted.  We say a few words and the sell to the highest bidder the space where people once gathered to hear the Word of the Lord and to receive His sacred feast.  I hate it.  I would rather the buildings be torn down than turned into community centers or art galleries or theaters or nightclubs or music venues or private homes.  If the churches are not going to preserve them, we owe it to ourselves and to the buildings no longer wanted or needed to prevent them from the sacrilege of misuse.  Okay, yes, I know.  We say a few words and deconsecrate them and so they are supposedly no different than any other structure.  Except that they still look like churches.

Growing up we often passed an old frame building that was once a thriving Lutheran congregation but it had been sold and moved and served as a hog house.  The shape of the windows told its story long after the markings of its sacred space had been removed or decayed.  Its steeple had been crudely cut off but everyone who saw it knew what had been there.  Not only the faithful knew, but even those who had never set foot in a church building before knew what this building had been and smelled what it was.  Shame on us!  A few shekels were more valuable to us than the sacred space in which couples had married, children baptized, youth confirmed, families grieved, faithful communed, and the songs of faith had rung out.  Shame on us!

If a church had been a warehouse in a previous life, most folks driving by still know what it had been.  The shape of churches is universal.  Signs can protest what the mind knows by instinct.  At least when such buildings are sold, they are returned to their first use and the temporary use as a house of God can rather easily be forgotten.  But churches that look like churches with the windows to the soul in their walls and a steeple pointing to heaven and chancels still carving out the holy of holies cannot be stripped of their identity simply by a few words.  What was designed into their bricks, stone, wood, and steel remains.  It is unmistakable.

Lets do us all a favor.  Lets not pretend what was never was and let us not presume that it makes no difference.  Instead, let us at least do the honorable thing and tear down what was set up for sacred usage so that no one is confused or scandalized and God is not mocked.  There are more and more church buildings coming on the market as Rome and others close down extraneous congregations and others die from within.  Protestantism has learned a terrible lesson about expediency and Rome has learned a terrible lesson about space and most of us just don't care anymore.  That is until you drive by one of those resurrected for less than holy purpose and then your skin just crawls.  

Thursday, July 31, 2025

Strange but true. . .

If you have the stomach for it, you can watch this snippet of a Roman Catholic Mass from the middle of June.  It is a great deal to digest.  The liturgical looseness is to be expected but the co-opting of a whole liturgy to accommodate an LGBTQIA+ agenda is rather shocking.  One can only hope that the chasuble in the chancel will never be worn.  I was surprised to hear that Rome is the most welcoming to LGBTQIA+ folks and their agenda and perhaps the authors if their Catechism might also be a little surprised.  Or maybe there is no shock or outrage left anymore.  No one should be surprised that their mission is directed to sex workers and trans folks in Kenya.  That said, the strangeness is not simply the liturgical quirks or the obvious LGBTQIA+ friendly atmosphere.  What makes this odd is that this is allowed while those who wish for Latin or ad orientum or reverence or kneeling are castigated, warned, and eventually shut down.  I wish I could say it were only true of Rome.  Sadly, it is not.

The day has come when those who cling to the traditions of the faithful are more and more seen as problem people in every denomination.  It is also true among Lutherans.  Pastors are warned against introducing change too quickly or without regard for the consciences of the people and particularly warned against such things as chanting, incense, and reverence.  At the same time, when pastors come in and put a drum set front and center and replace the organ with guitars, keyboards, and a beat the dominates the music, these pastors are lauded as missional and the people urged to care about those not in the pews enough to give up their sacred cows of liturgy, vestments, and ceremonies.  The vast majority of larger congregations offer at least one contemporary worship option and many of them have assigned the Divine Service to an unpopular time slot and this is still happening in Missouri.  

Why is it that those who take seriously the Confessional call to catholic doctrine and practice are so often singled out for criticism and those who live on the fringes of the church's liturgical life are considered pace setters and mission-minded?  The vast majority of LCMS congregations use the hymnal and at least the minimal ceremonial of that book but the vast majority of people in LCMS congregations worship in congregations that at least offers some form of blended or contemporary service.  Most of us who have a fuller liturgical celebration are less intent upon seeing what we do imposed on those who do less than we are the whole Synod adopting the Divine Service as minimum, the hymns of the hymnal as their song, and reverence as the character of what happens in worship.  We are not about sending a thurible to every address of every congregation in Synod but we are about a clear and unmistakable face to what happens on Sunday morning among us.  It may not be uniformity but it is at least unity.  Rome has the same problem.

Rome has its dioceses of Charlotte or Detroit or other places where bishops are silent as church mice about the extremes of liturgical practice and faith expressed but roar like lions against someone who wants to kneel to receive the Sacrament.  While I do not know of many Latin Mass folks who insist that it has to be Vetus Ordo, I do know that they expect the Novus Ordo to at least acknowledge in some way the kinship between the rites.  They long for unity even if they admit that uniformity may not be possible.  One it tolerated and, perhaps, even celebrated, while the other is constrained and forbidden.  One pope contradicts another on this subject and throws a tantrum over folks who want to be nearer what was the 500 year norm.  Sad but true, strange but true.  Leo has not yet signaled what he will do and Lutherans have no pope to insist upon anything so I suspect the status quo will remain for both Rome and Wittenberg.  It is easier to gang up on the catholics than to curb the excesses of the Protestants in nearly every denomination.

Wednesday, July 30, 2025

Birth rate does matter. . .

Although most have laughed and dismissed the idea that birth rate is responsible for a significant portion of Christianity's woes, the refusal to entertain this seriously does not mean that it is not true.  Birth rate does matter.  A Pew study from 2010 to 2020 indicates that Christianity is growing (at least in the Southern Hemisphere and Africa in particular) but it is also declining in its proportion to the whole of the world's population.  Conversion is still significant but the decline of births and the loss of the children born due to a lack of catechesis and example is what is more responsible for the state of affairs today. 

In the Pew study demographics were cited most as the explanation for the shift over the decade.  The religious groups with older populations and a falling birthrate are struggling to keep up with those who have younger members and who laud the larger family.  The religions in decline are distinctly those in which marriage is more and more optional and children are not essential.  Europe and North America certainly fill that bill as they have more singles, smaller families, and an aging population so the once dominant religion of that area, Christianity, now has and will have fewer members going forward.  In contrast, in Sub-Saharan Africa large families and high esteem for marriage along with a significant conversion rate means the number of Christians there is increasing.  

What is true of Christians in these areas is also true of the Islamic nations of the Middle East and Northern Africa.  It is also true at least of the newer immigrant populations in the West who also claim Islam as their faith.  Birth rates matter.  The Lutheran lands of old (Northern Europe and Scandinavia) are showing the worst effects of the loss of marriage as a cultural ideal and the loss of children as a high value of marriage.  As someone once said, as goes Western Europe, soon goes America, and as goes America, so goes Christianity in the West.  I once saw that credited to Adrian Rodgers, the Southern Baptist preacher of a previous generation but it is a case of the obvious.

My point today is to say that the future of Christianity -- in particular in the West but literally everywhere -- depends upon the healthy state of the family, recovery of marriage as the norm, and the rejection of abortion and birth control out of the desire to enjoy larger families.  We cannot evangelize ourselves out of our decline.  There are plenty of people to be evangelized and I am not at all suggesting that we should not make a public proclamation of the Gospel.  Just the opposite.  But the reality is that we could speed up adult conversions in the West and still see our overall Christian population continue to diminish.  The key to the health of the West is the same as the key to the health of Christianity in the West -- the recovery of the value and virtue of marriage and children.  Christianity, however, has to do a better job of retaining our children in the face of a growing secular influence in public education and a culture more and more unfriendly to the faith.  This will mean some hard choices for those parents and families and a change in the values of Christians to be more distinct from the rest of the population.  Surely this is not a bad thing. 

Christianity has suffered as the decision of our ancestors in the early 1930s and 1940s was to embrace birth control and normalize the ideal of a smaller family.  It has also suffered in the large number of Christian denominations who were late to the battle against abortion, no-fault divorce, and the full embrace of the sexual revolution in the plethora of sexual desires and gender identities that has now become normal.  Other Christian denominations chose not to join the fight at all and simply caved into the prevailing direction of secular culture.  Orthodoxy and catechesis are the ongoing causes by which Christians not only retain the faith but keep the faithful in that faith.  This is a profound lesson we should have learned but the reality is that it is hard for us now to stand out and against what has become the norm in the West.  It will be going forward as well. 

Finally, while Christians do better than we assume at evangelizing, for every 18 folks who walk through the front door, 5-6 walk out the back door.  Muslims do a terrible job of converting with barely 2 new folks walking through the front door but they do not lose many and so their trajectory is always pointed higher than Christianity as a whole.  This is where catechesis enters in -- not simply the formal instruction that takes place at the church building but the catechesis of the home in which mom and dad impart the faith, model it, and help it grow in their children.  Many of the folks who left Christianity simply were never there in the first place.  They had not been assimilated as children or as adults and so a faith that remained on the outside of their lives became easy to jettison at the first sign of trouble or disappointment.  We are not doing a bad job of welcoming new people but we are not doing a very good job of modeling, instructing, and helping them in the doctrine and piety of the faith.  If we had, the gains we registered at the front door would not be so diluted by those exiting the back door. 

Tuesday, July 29, 2025

Better in theory than in practice. . .

There is no limit to the things which might fit the phrase better in theory than in practice.  I could certainly add a number to that category.  Among them is Missouri's preoccupation with democracy and voting which seems clear in theory (both the rationale and its limits against voting on the Word of God) but in practice it is neither neat nor tidy.  Too often we end up confusing majority with God's will and actually voting on the things God's Word prescribes.  Lutheran moderation seems good in theory but in practice it often makes it difficult for us to actually say that certain things are wrong and you should not do them.  Furthermore, it can end up being a subtle justification for sinning as long as the sins are not too shocking or terrible.

Sola Scriptura sounds great in theory but in practice it has ended up robbing Protestantism of anything remotely near catholic doctrine and truth.  Even if it is not how it is intended, the reality has certainly been that everyone is his own interpreter and his own sancta mater ecclesium and magisterium.  Those who claim to be bound by only the Scriptures have seen their churches waffle on abortion and cave to birth control and embrace every kind of sexual desire and gender identity -- to name but a few of the errors.  Even those who have abandoned the phrase, think that they are operating under the authority of Scripture when they are embracing the times

Even bishops are far better in theory than in practice.  If bishops alone were a guarantee of orthodoxy, Methodists and Episcopalians would not be the rather lost causes they have become and the ELCA would not be on the brink of apostasy.  Yes, I still believe it is better to emulate the ordered structure of Christianity from the beginning than to put things into American democratic terminology but we all know that changing the terminology will not fix the errors.  The same can be said about liturgy and ceremony -- they are profoundly catholic and apostolic but it is not impossible to keep the forms while emptying them of their meaning.  The Church of England seems to have excelled at keeping the shape of things while gutting the doctrine and piety from the ritual and forms of the Mass.

Councils are often great when they confess the truth of Scripture but when they authority of the council becomes the equal to the Word of God or when its power is separated from that Word, the councils become confused conventions of votes and voters who think they are doing one thing while they are often doing something else.  The Reformation was correct in warning us that councils can err and they have and they will continue to do so.  The sole source and norm of catholic doctrine is the Scriptures and the sole reflection of the Scriptures in worship remains the ordo, the liturgical form that belongs to all even when they have chosen to depart from it.  No restoration of faith can happen without a restoration of worship and the other way around.  The search for authority often leads us everywhere when it needs to lead us to the somewhere that is God's unchanging Word. 

There is no silver bullet.  Every age and generation must signal its devotion to orthodox and Scriptural Christianity, make the good confession before the errors and temptations of the day, and stand upon the unchanging foundation of Christ alone.  We cannot afford to become complacent because we call the offices by the right names or keep the ancient form of the Mass or hold to the slogans of another fight.  Ours is never the cause to pause and refresh but to remain ever vigilant against errors that would steal Christ and our salvation and ever urgent in confessing clearly and completely the sacred deposit of the faith and its foundations upon Scripture and its witness in catholic tradition.  There is way that we will lose this and that is when our own voices and the voices of those outside the faith become equal to the voice of Scripture and when our custom becomes the equivalent of apostolic custom.  When that happens it is sure that trouble and decay will soon follow. 

Monday, July 28, 2025

I am . . . a recovering Christian. . .

There is a pastor in Arkansas who purports to be Lutheran (albeit ELCA) and a decade or so ago he had a blog in which he introduced himself in this way:  Hi, my name is Clint, and I'm the least bible-minded pastor in America.  It is a good tag line and sure to arouse some interest in the crowded blog marketplace.  But it is also a terrible indictment against someone and the denomination in which they live.  When faced with the question, Do you believe strongly in the accuracy of the bible?  Schneckloth said he would have answered, No.  If he does not strongly believe in the accuracy of the Scriptures, what is the ground and norm of his faith or of any faith?

He is not alone.  There is no shortage of people who see some things in the Bible as worthy but who discard most of it as either unreliable or inaccurate or hopelessly out of date and out of step with the times.  In fact, there are many Lutherans who do so.  Not all of them are on the lunatic fringe but, indeed, most of them see themselves and believe themselves to be faithful and even exemplary in this regard.  Blindly following the Bible is seen as cultish while taking the Bible with a grain of salt and a healthy dose of reason is seen as enlightened.  Indeed, there are many who think themselves in the mainstream or even conservative but who allow their reason to dictate to the Scriptures.  

Notably, the realm of this is typically morality and the social gospel.  More important than echoing the language of Scripture or calling people to repentance is standing with the oppressed, advocating on behalf those without power, and identifying with them.  It becomes less about sin and redemption and more about freedom and service.  Strange as it seems, I would suggest that it cannot be about freedom and service until it is first about sin and redemption.  You simply cannot get there from here unless the road leads through the cross where the Savior gave His life as a ransom for many.  Again, the problem here is not that this language is necessarily wrong but it is placed above the cross where sin's debt was paid and it transforms the Gospel into a principle (see yesterday's post).  Jesus act of redemption is not to save you from something but for something and, in particular, for this life and for the difference you can make today.

Somewhere along the way I read this man's post quoting another author but in agreement:  don't make the mistake of treating this language too literally, turning metaphor into mechanism, poetry into ledger sheets.  The Bible is a book of symbolic language, of metaphor and myth, and of poetry instead of prose.  We are all tempted to this because symbolic language does not demand anything of us and it certainly does not give us anything of substance.  We are all tempted to this because metaphors are to be appreciated and do not convict us of sin nor direct us to the cross where sin's redemption was made.  We are all tempted to this because poetry is about the language as much as it is about what it says.  We want the Gospel to be this way as well.

Reason and education seem to help us believe that the cross of Christ is about everything but sin and forgiveness, that the Gospel is about how we live as much as about what Christ has done, and the life we need to be concerned about is how to live life now -- not eternal life.  The end result is that we are ever more distant from the cross and from the new life Christ has accomplished and the ball ends up back in our own court.  The guy I am speaking about is nothing if he is not eloquent and logical and even passionate.  The problem is he is simply wrong.  You cannot get there, where he wants to be, without the cross as Christ's surrendered life a ransom paid for sin, a satisfaction offered to the Father to appease God's wrath, and a propiatory sacrifice (as in 1 John 2:2 or Hebrews 2).   If redemption is symbolic, then sin is symbolic.  If the cross is only an example, it is not an altar where Christ gave Himself a sacrifice for our sin.  If the story is poetry (sort of an elaborated version of Abraham sacrificing his son), then our life in the Spirit is poetry and not prose (less about right and wrong than about authenticity).  It is no wonder that in the end it is so easy to go from the cross to causes like gender affirming treatment of pre-adolesents or just about anything else on the trendy wave of the moment.  In the end, you begin to realize that words like these tell you something.  Voices like this are telling you they are recovering Christians, trying to get away from the eternal Gospel proclaimed down through the ages and not looking to get closer. 

 

Sunday, July 27, 2025

Concrete or symbolic language. . .

The great challenge in Christianity is to speak in the same concrete terminology that Scripture does and to stay away from symbolic language.  Indeed, the genius of the creeds are that they speak with one voice the one language of Scripture to say who God is and who He is not.  Too often we forego the language of creed and confession and end up with sentimental images or symbolic descriptions of who God is like but without the dynamic power of Scripture, creed, and confession that speak concretely of this God and what He has done.  God is not like anything.  God is who He is -- which goes back to the very name of God in the Old Testament.  I am who I am.  That is why we fail so when we treat God in the language of feeling or image or symbol.  We try to compare God to something and inevitably to us and therefore fall into the trap of the Roman and Greco pantheon of deities.  God is me magnified.  Scripture insists that this is the worst distortion of God and so commands us not to make a graven image of God.  What this means is not simply the carving of a stone deity but the crafting of language about God or likening God to something else but failing to use the terms Scripture uses.  This too is idolatry and blasphemy.

Because the social sciences frequently use this kind of language, we are all tempted to use it of God and to find commonalities where disparities exist.  Everyone worships something has come to mean that worship is not God addressing us but we addressing Him -- even defining Him.  So immediately the self-disclosure of God is forgotten in favor of how all imagined gods are worshiped, how they have been worshiped over time, and what the worship of Old and New Testament has in common with them.  The Achilles heel of this argument is that God is not the accumulation of all our quests for meaning or understanding or reason to allay our fears, worries, or doubts.  God is unique, known not by postulating ideas of Him but by knowing Him through His own revelation of Himself.

Scripture is blunt.  The only God who is God is the crucified and risen Lord.  There is no path to heaven or to God apart from this path and this God who reveals Himself and His love in suffering for sin not His own and rising to bestow upon the mortals immortality.  It is concrete.  Know this Savior and you know the Father for they are one.  The Spirit is not some sort of ethereal reality to transcend the concrete of this life but the power to bring the Word to life in us, to teach us to believe, and to empower us to live holy, upright, and godly lives within the framework of this present mortality.

Theology has devolved into attempts to explain things or render them rational or to impart to the concrete a higher value or plane of existence than the mortal.  In this way theology has become untethered from that which gives it meaning or value.  In this sense, every real theology is Biblical theology and every real Biblical theology is Christology.  We do not put God in this cage but God has revealed Himself to us in this way and refuses to be known by other ways.    Within the spiritual hunger of our times for meaning, purpose, reason, and hope do live those who attempt to offer metaphysical answers to concrete questions.  Some of them sound good and take us in as if we have found a voice which can live within the rickety framework of imagined religion as well as the concrete framework of revealed religion.  Jordan Peterson is one of those figures in this moment but there are many who have come before him and many who will follow him.  The problem is that where the world wants to find ambiguity and type, God is certain and concrete and this is why He is always a stumbling block without the aid of the Spirit to awaken us to faith.

Religion is not love in the abstract or even our love for Him or one another but God's love for us.  Scripture insists upon this.  There is no religion in love welling up from within us but only the first love of God for us.  This is what love means and we see it in the cross and empty tomb.  This love is not words or symbols for suffering endured and blood shed.  It is almost laughable how quickly love in Christianity has come to mean advocacy for the disaffected masses in need.  It is entirely predictable but tragic how noble Christian charity has become an NGO using tax dollars to do what Christ has called us to do.   Love has joined the corrupted words like mission and evangelism which does just about anything but speak Christ so the Spirit can call, gather, enlighten, and sanctify a people to gather around the Word preached and taught, the baptismal water washing clean, and the Eucharistic bread and wine to satisfy all hunger and thirst.  How odd it is that we are more comfortable with love that tells somebody's story but does not cross the road and bind up wounds or water that symbolizes everything but does nothing or the Real Presence which is absent in bread and wine only to live in the heart!

The world keeps asking what God is like and we must tell them who God is.  The congregation gathers to know what life in the Spirit is like and we must tell them it is living within the life of God through the means of grace.  The work of the church keeps asking how to make a big difference and we must tell them love always works one on one.  The guilty seek forgiveness as if it were merely a verdict granted to them that they are okay and we must continue to call them to repentance and absolve them so that they might be the new people God has declared them in baptism.  The people are itching to pray and tell God what they want God to know and do and we must continue to remind them that the mightiest prayer of all is three words: Lord, have mercy.  Nobody is saved by the idea of God but everyone who calls upon the Name of the Lord Jesus Christ shall be saved.

Saturday, July 26, 2025

In the spirit of. . .

I wish that phrase had never been invented.  The spirit of something is so often used as the justification for the very things that betray what it is whose spirit you are invoking.  The Roman Catholics do it with respect to Vatican II.  In the spirit of Vatican II, a great number of inventions were made to transform the Mass almost overnight and yet nothing of what was invented was mandated or even discussed at Vatican II.  I find it amusing when this kind of discussion takes place among my Roman friends.  I should not be amused by it.  It happens among Lutherans as well.  It happens among all of us.

We Lutherans talk about the spirit of the Confessions as if they were different from the actual words, the spirit of the liturgy as if it were something distinct from the words or form or ceremonies of the liturgy, the spirit of friendship as if if were different from friendship itself, etc...   We talk about the spirit of Lutheranism as if Lutheranism had a spirit apart from the Holy Spirit.  How goofy is that?!  

The worst way we do this is to speak of the spirit of the Gospel.  The Gospel is not something which has a spirit (again, other than the Holy Spirit).  There is no spirit of the Gospel which is distinct from the Gospel of Christ crucified and risen.  You cannot speak of the Gospel spirit as if it were different from its words.  You should not speak of the Gospel as if it were something that could be reduced to a principle or a spirit.  Every time we invoke the spirit of something, we are in danger of violating what it is that we invoke.

For example, when Christians invoke the spirit of the Gospel to recognize same sex marriage or regularize same sex attraction or justify gender dysphoria, we are violating the very words of that Gospel to do so and betray what it is that we are invoking.  When we invoke the spirit of the Gospel to minimize doctrine and teaching and catechesis in favor of a broad church in which everyone gets to believe what they want, we get that spirit wrong and end up using the Gospel to justify or make normal that which the Gospel has come to forgive.  When we call people to repent for things other than real sins, we are in danger of turning sin into something other than the things which God has forbidden and we are in danger of turning the things God has forbidden into mere suggestions.

Whenever someone talks about doing something in the spirit of..., that should engage your warning radar because without a doubt whatever is being urged in the spirit of will actually be in direct opposition to or at least a distortion of that of which the spirit is invoked.  Plus, the real thing is always better than that which is the spirit of it.  The real food you chew and savor is better than the imagined and the real meat is better than the fake meat in the spirit of beef.  The real Gospel is so much better than the spirit of it.  The real liturgy is so much better than the spirit of it.  The real Christ is so much better than the spirit of Jesus (not meaning Holy Spirit, by the way).  So don't let someone lead you from the real thing because somebody is telling you about the spirit of it.

 

Friday, July 25, 2025

God really loves life. . .

One of the most problematic distinctions between God and man is life.  God really does love life -- in all its forms, shapes, sizes, and value.  He loves the lilies of the fields and the child in the womb, the forest and all its creatures and the aged in a nursing home.  God really does love life.  Surely that is the first lesson of Genesis and its revelation of God's creation -- He loves what He has made even after sin entered the world and we rebelled against our Creator.  That is the most amazing thing about God's love for life -- it is not conditional upon us or some idea of what we can do for Him.  He loved us even to sending forth His Son in our flesh to suffer and die and rise again not for the good or the almost good or even the lovable but for sinners! 

We don't love life -- at least the we of our culture and even perhaps many within the Church.  We love our lives until we don't anymore and wish to end them painlessly as if this were our right.  We love a good life, a well-lived life, a rich and productive life but we are quick to judge the value of the lives of those whom we do not believe live such a life.  We love the young and the beautiful but we are ready to discard the lives of the disabled, the unwanted, and the elderly.  We love the lives of the iconic, the famous, and the powerful but we do not love the weak, the poor, the needy, or the homeless.  Yes, we do advocate for them but is the love of advocacy more than the love of those in need.  We love those who make our lives better but we do not love those who cost us something, those hard to love, or those who different from us.  Yes, we do love the idea of diversity but we would rather people were just like us.  I should not need to go on.  You get the idea.

We don't love life especially the lives of those whom we judge to be guilty of the sins I judge to be the worst -- we do not love rapists or murderers or child abusers.  Yet the miracle is that God loves them, loves every sinner, and loves them so much He burns with fire for their repentance and salvation.  This makes God a stranger to us as much as anything else.  If God were like us, He would know better.  Some lives are worth more than others and some are simply not worth anything.  But God's mercy is beyond our human reason.  God really does love all life.  Our struggle in faith is not simply the struggle to believe that God can love us with this powerful and redemptive love but to believe that God actually does love others and especially the others we do not love.

Now to be sure, God does not love our sins.  He loves us enough for His Son to be covered in them and render Him ugly with our unrighteous thoughts, words, and deeds.  He does not love us with the kind of passive love that accepts and tolerates our sins or our own attempts to make up for them but He loves us sinners.  We do not have to love the sins of others in order to love them but we dare not set up their sins as excuses or justifications for loving some but not them.  God loves life and values the lives of sinners even though He hates sin and His Son has bled and died to pay for those sins.  So maybe we need to learn something about His love so that we may love one another as He has loved us.  By the way, I read that last thing somewhere.

Thursday, July 24, 2025

NPR and PBS

I am an avid watcher of NPR and NPT.  I do not financially support them.  I love that they provide the BritBox fare of Masterpiece, to the Antiques Roadshow, and so many other programs I enjoy.  I do not pay much attention to their news programs or to their social programming.  I much prefer Lawrence Welk and Hyacinth Bucket to their political point of view.  It saddens me that they are seemingly blind to this slant and presume that everyone from rural America to the hicks in the South are as dependent upon their news and political commentary as are the erudite liberals of the coasts and educational institutions.  I am sad that the loss of governmental money might reduce some of the programming I enjoy but I can always tune into BritBox directly to satisfy me even though it is often easier to turn on my TV and get it from the local national public whatever stations.  The whole idea that without governmental support and without the voice of public television there will be people who will not get the unvarnished truth is laughable.  My local station is running a financial campaign to make up for the loss of the government money and insists that they are the only ones who ask the "hard questions."  As most folks know already, news media hardly ever asks the hard questions of those whom they support and nearly always uses their hard questions to challenge the people they do not support. 

I gave up on NPR when the local station decided that experimental music was better than classical and relegated their small offering to some HD channel I cannot get in my car.  You would have thought they might keep classical music since it is supposed to be high brow but now they are more interested in music programmed by LGBTQIA+ than the masters -- not unlike some symphony orchestra and their programming directors.  I cannot tell you how many times I have tuned into public radio or television only to roll my eyes at their seemingly naivete in displaying a blatant political slant to what is supposed to be neutral news and commentary.  However, since the rest of the media has presumed that their job is to tell us what the news means (commentary) instead of giving us the facts, why would we expect the public versions of that media not to follow suit?  Thus my growing disdain for nearly all media but in particular for one which enjoys governmental support.

That said, there might be a lesson here.  Although the IRS and government seems to be loosening the rules with respect to churches and politics, there is a cost to be borne by becoming political.  Yes, the churches do need to address moral issues without restraint but identifying with a particular political party or cause has the downside of diluting what is our own essential purpose.  We are here to proclaim the Gospel of Christ crucified and risen.  Everything flows from that but, more importantly, is less important than this.  

The reality is the politics have always been connected to churches.  Some wags once suggested that the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod was the Republican Party at prayer.  While not technically accurate since survey after survey has indicated this is not a true stereotype, the tag has stuck.  Roman Catholics were once universally seen as Democrats.  Again, while it was never quite as true as the image of it, the stereotype stuck.  We are not about parties but issues that flow from our confession, not about candidates but about positions, not about telling people who to vote for but urging them to vote from an informed Christian perspective.  That will always lead to different outcomes and no party mirrors the causes and concerns of the Church.  Public television and radio forgot that along the way and we dare not follow them in this dead end path.  If churches enter the stage with an opinion, it better be clear why this issue is one of confession and creed and not simply another attempt to sell a point of view.  Without this, it won't be long before the IRS changes its mind and without Christ as our proclamation we will become merely another slanted outlet for opinions.  Under it all it better be the Word of the Lord that endures forever.

 

UPDATE:

The Corporation for Public Broadcasting was created by Congress as a vehicle to fund public broadcast stations.  On the other hand, Planned Parenthood is a private entity.  Odd, however, that Planned Parenthood, a non-government corporation, got more money, and, even more significant, a greater percentage of its revenue, from taxpayers than CPB was. So Planned Parenthood was also more reliant on federal funding than PBS or NPR ever were. One out of every $8 in NPR OR PBS came from the government while $1 out of every $3 went to Planned Parenthood.  Either public broadcasting was doing something wrong or our values were skewed toward the work Planned Parenthood does (and still does in this when abortion has become a pill).  Why did NPR and PBS not complain about this?  R


Wednesday, July 23, 2025

As worthless as. . .

From the farm we had the completion of the phrase  this title began and it is not pretty -- even though it is mostly true.  So much of what the Church is and does is exactly that according to the world -- worthless and useless.  It is, as one author entitled her book on worship, A Royal Waste of Time.  I will not dispute this conclusion.  From the point of view of the world, God is mostly worthless and without use except as a convenient target, scapegoat, and blame for the things you do not like or want or have gone wrong.  Other than this, why do you need or want a God or His Church?  

There was a time in which no one said such a thing out loud.  You may have thought it but in public in America, Church was as American as apple pie and Chevrolet.  God was an American, as true blue a patriot in the eyes of our society as anyone.  Those days are long gone.  With gluten intolerance and diabetes and concern for organic and fresh supplies, apple pies are not what they once were.  Chevrolet is not exactly what it once was when the chairman could quip that what was good for General Motors was good for America.  Even those within the Church do not call God an American anymore and it seems that churches and the Church are at best tolerated and at worst despised across the culture of our land today.  Nobody seems to want either around anymore and some are hoping to tax them both out of existence.

If you are outside the Church, I suppose there is no more logical conclusion than to think God useless and the Church worthless.  Even the old charities once so intimately connected with the churches have become largely NGOs who work on the government's dime doing the government's business and not God's or the churches.  But many things seem to have been jettisoned by the times.  We no longer value or share a great moral vision in our land -- not about the sacred character of life from its natural beginning to its natural end, not about what it means to be male or female, not about the centrality of marriage and family, not about the blessing of children, not about a work ethic, not about social interaction, and not even what it means to be spiritual or religious.  Our individualism and our consumer and entertainment culture has isolated us from each other and built invisible barriers that divide us even more than walls.  Ear buds and small screens are more important to us that community or fellowship of any kind -- especially religious.

Lets face it.  Christianity is a hard sell to a people who find most of what is Christian worthless and useless.  But it is not our job to insist that Christianity is worth something or everything or to argue them into seeing how useful it and God and the Church are to have around.  Our calling is to proclaim the Gospel, to call a people to repentance, to baptize and to absolve, to catechize and instruct, to feed and serve.  What God does with our labors is not given for us to define or judge.  We simply do what we have been called to do and as faithfully as we can do it.  Each of us in our stations in life and all of us as the Church doing and serving as faithfully as we are able -- that is our job.  The worth or value of God and the Church are the fruit of faith and not the reason to believe.  The cross is that reason and the Spirit is that power.  Once a person called me as a pastor a blood sucking leech.  Okay.  But thankfully God has defined my worth not by what I do but what He has done for me.  Tell that to the world.  It may not sell but it will probably make for more Christians. 

Tuesday, July 22, 2025

Is anyone sounding the alarm?

I am much more familiar with the stats in the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod and these are by no means encouraging.  Yet the reality is the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America is in even worse shape.  Now no one in their right might takes comfort in the fact that as bad as we are doing, others are doing worse.  If you do, I am sad for you.  I don't.  Remembering the days when we were both growing by a new congregation every week or less and TIME was wondering if everyone in America would be Lutheran in the year 2000, I grieve not over the loss of power or prestige but of vibrancy in our life around the Word and Sacrament, seriousness for the task given us, confidence in the Word to guide and answer our questions and the worlds, and hope for the future.  In both denominations, doom and gloom and a mind for expediency or ignorance seems to be our temptation.  That said, a bishop of the ELCA has given a sober assessment of the state of that church body.

  • Over the last 10 years, the percentage of the smallest congregations with fewer than 50 people has doubled.
  • 58% of ELCA congregations have fewer than 50 people.
  • Congregations that worship with over 250 people in attendance decreased from 9% to 2% over the last eight years.
  • From 2015 to 2023, The ELCA lost 834 congregations. Of these, 520 closed, 131 merged into another congregation, 142 left, and 41 were removed.
  • The ELCA ordains about 200 pastors a year, while 400 pastors retire each year. Currently, there are over 600 ELCA churches seeking a pastor.
  • 45% of ELCA congregations cannot afford a full-time pastor.  

The ELCA ordains 200 pastors a year, sees about 400 pastors retire each year, and has over 600 parishes calling a pastor (not counting permanent vacancies).  In the LCMS we are smaller by the numbers but have about 115 or more new pastors every year and has 500+ calling (with many of those calls for part-time pastors).  These stats cast a long shadow over us.  We seem not to lack money as much as people, not congregations but growing congregations, not pastors but young pastors who can be expected to serve 35-40+ years.  That is what we share in common with a denomination that also calls itself Lutheran though looks very different from us.

This is one of the poisonous fruits born of distraction.  Missouri continues to be distracted by worship wars, evangelicalism, congregationalism, and the lingering skirmishes of the last Battle for the Bible.  The ELCA seems to find it hard to reject a cultural cause that has anything to do with sex or gender.  When the dust settles, both church bodies find it easier to fixate on the distractions than take up the cause of the Gospel of Christ crucified and risen.  Both find it hard to give full attention to the mission of calling sinners to repentance, absolving them of their sins, and raising them up to new and everlasting lives in baptism.  Both have been lax in their catechesis and now it shows in the generations lost by failing to teach this Gospel in the home and at the Church.  Both have been lazy about youth, preferring to entertain more than challenge them with the faith of the Scriptures and Confessions.  Both are reaping the fruits of a culture of divorce and of a devaluation of marriage and children.  We all owe it to the Lord of the Church and to the future to admit our past, lay it before the Cross, and rise up renewed to do better.

If I had to predict the future, I would find more hope for Missouri than the ELCA.  Already their ecumenical partnerships have weakened the Lutheran identity at their seminaries, blurred in the minds of the people what difference there is between Lutherans, Reformed, Presbyterian, etc..., and muddied what it is that Lutherans actually believe and confess.  This provides them with short term pulpit supply from whoever is available but long term problems coming up for a rationale for the ELCA.  Missouri, for all its problems, it is much more homogeneous in belief and practice even though our disputes dominate the headlines and, as long as we keep the two seminary route, we will also have a much more theologically and pastorally united ministerium.  The numbers are not the issue and we should not fixate on them.  But they are a warning shot to remind us that distraction from or abandonment of the Scriptures and our Confessions will hurt us even more deeply and steal the vitality from our mission.  The demise of either body is certainly possible but the faith we confess is not for the benefit of how we feel about ourselves.  It is about the lost and the Good Shepherd who has called us to labor for Him in finding them and making them part of His flock so that He may shepherd them to the rich green pastures and the cool quiet waters of everlasting life. 

Monday, July 21, 2025

Is there a right to die?

I have written before on the right to die.  Our neighbors to the North have taken the lead in both the availability of this option as well as its exercise.  It is not an example we ought to follow.  I read a month ago or so in the New York Times Magazine a very long article giving particular focus to this issue.  In the title is the challenge:  Do patients without a terminal illness have a right to die?  It would take far more space than I have here or time to give fair treatment to the many cases of nonterminally ill people being helped to death by physicians in Canada.  You may call it doctors killing their patients intentionally.  That said, it is something we need to keep in our conversation because there are voices here who think that we should make it all uniformly legal (as some states have moved toward).

The stories cry out for an answer -- chronic depression, chronic pain, histories of abuse, failed attempts at suicide in the past, loneliness, poverty, the loss of family and friends.  Why, it would seem that individuals whose lives are already spiraling toward death are owed a painless, easy, and cost free way to end their suffering!  Do they?  Is there a threshold of pain, suffering, and hardship in which death is not only the end of what hurts but a positive step toward peace?  The world cries out for moral leadership in an age unwilling to spend the time necessary to give such hard questions their due.  The churches who proclaim the resurrection without fear should also without fear proclaim that death is not our choice.

Quoting from the NY Times Magazine:

Fundamentally, he [the death doctor] didn’t think the best way to protect poor and marginalized patients was to force them to stay alive, because in some counterfactual version of events, in which the world was a better and more just place, they might have chosen differently. That wasn’t how anything in medicine worked; a doctor always treated the patient as she was. How could it be otherwise? If only those who were rich or well connected were recognized to have autonomy and allowed to choose? . . .

He had read the report from Paula’s neurologist, which said that Paula did not have permanent brain damage and was not eligible for MAID. But he thought the specialist, who was not a MAID provider herself, misunderstood the eligibility criteria. There was nothing in the law that said that Paula’s neurological condition had to be tied to actual, physical damage to the brain. Paula’s pain was real either way. She felt it the same either way.

Doctors, who once were bound by the pledge to do no harm, have repeatedly pushed euthanasia upon those without terminal illness in Canada for years.  Teams of physicians routinely counsel those with such pain or illness to positively consider assisted suicide or, to put it more accurately, euthanasia.  Death is, according to them, a more compassionate choice than life.  It has become the mark of our compassion not to serve the suffering but to end their suffering with euthanasia or assisted suicide and to become the advocate of such death even for those without terminal illness.  This is not medicine.  Finding a doctor willing to kill you is not finding a friend.

Ill and disabled Canadians with non-life-threatening but serious conditions often do not receive nor are they promised prompt medical treatment with some waiting months or even years for such help.  At the same time, however, some of Canada's disabled and non-terminally-ill patients are found not only eligible for euthanasia but fast-tracked toward such a death.  In an amazing statement of efficiency, such a death  can happen within 90 days of the patient being found qualified.  Those patients who can find a doctor to certify that their deaths are “reasonably foreseeable,” face no waiting time once that eligibility has been established.  Is this what we want to learn from looking to our neighbor to the North -- how to be more efficient in killing the patient than in treating them?

Delaware is close to enacting such laws to allow this.  So is the UK.  Sadly, churches find opposition to their anti-death stance even from folks in their pews.  We are so conditioned to think that suffering is the worst thing of all and anything which can end suffering is good that we no longer think through the consequences of allowing physician assisted suicide or euthanasia.  How odd it is that we seem to face hurdle after hurdle to end the lives of those who have been given a death sentence for the horrid nature of their crimes but we can throw together a death cocktail at a moment's notice!  Is this truly the mark of an enlightened civilization or is it the mark of its decline?  

Some would insist that right-to-lifers are trying to make choices for the people but the reality is that we are trying to slow things down lest those who believe someone's life is not worth living are given a short cut to ending that life.  I have great respect for physicians but I do not believe that this belongs to any doctor to make the judgment call to bring an end to a life.  Surely there are circumstances when nothing more can be done except palliative care and awaiting the will of God but these are not justifications to put a figurative gun in the hands of those whose job is to help and not to hurt, to preserve life and not to end it.  If we cannot get it right on basic issues of life and death, we are in a sorry state and it just might be that the churches have failed in their role as teachers and advocates for the cause of life -- the life given and redeemed by our merciful Lord.

 

 

Sunday, July 20, 2025

Law and Gospel

I grew up with the admonition that politeness and courtesy were never optional.  Whether you faced people you despised or were looking across the table at your enemies, the uncommon common virtues of politeness were not to be forgotten.  Maybe it is the perennial niceness of the Swedish culture or the stoic face of the German ancestry, but the truth is I find it hard to preach the Law in full accusatory manner.  Never mind that I am a wimp at heart, would rather have my folks love me, and grew up in an age in which the Law was preached always to us and not to you, the truth is I find it hard to speak the Law with the full weight of its power in personal address to the hearer.  I suspect I am not alone.

On one hand, the Law is silent because people think anything said about sin or any call to repentance or any encouragement to holiness of life and conduct is an attempt to elevate yourself above others.  In particular, the preacher finds out how quickly someone replies to the Law rightly proclaimed by saying "Your not perfect, either."  Well, that goes without saying now doesn't it?  If preachers had to pass a sin test before mounting the pulpit, there would be no preaching.  Even saintly St. Paul lamented loud and often his own sin and unworthiness -- all the while preaching loud and often the Law and calling the people of God to walk worthy.

On the other hand, the Law is unwelcome because people misunderstand the Gospel.  Those who presume that Jesus died so that we would no longer talk about sin or there would no longer be anything called sin have a false idea of the Gospel.  The cross only makes sense if sin is deep enough and powerful enough to keep us from cleaning up our own house and setting ourselves right before the Father.  Otherwise, it is a cruel joke to have Jesus suffer and die only to prove He loves us.  Jesus did not die to silence the Law but to fulfill it.  No longer can anyone claim a righteousness before the Law nor should they.  Christ is our righteousness.  That said, this Gospel does not erase the call to be holy as God is holy.  The call to Christian living has been muted by those who insist God wants us to be happy even if what makes us happy is contrary to His Word.  With this, the Gospel has become less about Jesus than a principle of love, acceptance, and toleration in which we judge no one and nothing wrong (except the things that would keep us from doing what we want).

I will say this.  We tend to preach as preachers and hear as hearers through the lens of our own weakness, pain, and shame.  This is the problem for those who mount the pulpit and this is the problem for those who sit in the pews.  We have selective hearing and we speak selectively.  This is a problem for the Law but it is also a Gospel issue.  Pastors find it hard to preach on sensitive topics that some will take wrongly and people are glad for pastors who shy away from those subjects.  In so doing, however, we blunt the Law AND the Gospel.  Jesus' blood has taken on every sin but if we are not ready to address sin with the blood of Christ, people will still live in bondage to sin.  Pastors need to be set free from their fears of what people might think but the people need to be set free from their sin through the Gospel.  All of this requires and expects that both will be preached honestly and fairly -- not as a recipe for a good sermon but as the text itself addresses and expects.  That is the value of the lectionary.  It forces preachers to take on topics they might rather ignore and to address them honestly.  I would be lying if I did not admit that sometimes I winced after proclaiming the text and then saying "The Gospel of the Lord."  Some of them did not quite sound like happy words.  But the Gospel is not about happiness.  It is always about holiness.  The goal of the preacher matches the goal of Scripture -- not to make us happy but to make us holy through the blood of Christ and to transform our hearts to desire such holiness.  The Spirit's work makes this hit home and turns the sermon from lecture into real preaching.