Making messes. . .

I will pick on Pope Francis because he is not here to argue with me.  I suspect, however, he would not argue.  He saw as his mission and purpose to make messes for the Lord.  In places and times when the need was for clarity, he was obtuse.  In places and times when the need was for bring people together, he seemed to delight in actually creating conflict.  In places and times when the need was for patience and deliberation, he seemed to act upon whim or impulse.  In places and times when the need was for holding to the faith once delivered, he seemed to press the edge of change and innovation in a way that actually undermined the tradition and dismissed it.  

Pope Francis actually left his successor many messes.  Some of them were people (Victor Fernández).  Some of them were moto proprios (Traditionis custodes or Fiducia Supplicans}.  Some of them were initiatives (governance of Rome or synodality).  I could go on.  I do not need to.  You get it.  He stirred the pot and then looked offended when somebody caught him with the spoon.  There are those in every organization and in the Church who like to do what Francis did -- make messes.  While it is easy to blame those who make the mess, that does nothing to clean it up.  Cleaning up is, after all, the goal.  It would be good if you were steward of the Church on any level that you leave to your successors not messes but things as clean and orderly as possible.  That is good on the parish level and it is good on every other level as well.

We find that in Lutheranism as well.  Rome is not the only one who has a few mess makers.  Our own LCMS seems to have enough folks who like to render obtuse what is clear, to focus uncertainty what is certain, and to simply irritate folks for the sake of watching how it all plays out.  I have no problem with conflict when it concerns that for which we dare not compromise or waver but I am deeply suspicious of salacious headlines and threats that masquerade as concerns.  Sometimes we need to call out those who simply delight in making messes and watching what happens.  It is simply not helpful when we spend the majority of our time trying to clean up the messes others have left to us.  It is wearisome to constantly be putting out fires or throwing oil on troubled waters.  We should all be working to prevent messes and where they exist to clean them up and to making sure that if we must create a mess it is for essential purpose and need.

I speak this largely to those entrusted with offices in the churches but I also commend this to those who hold no office except that of baptized child of God.  We live in an age in which the internet allows us to make known to the world things which could be handled with some discretion.  Hitting post is a delightful way to get rid of our frustration but at what cost?  I know that there are times when we cannot help but make a mess in the process of cleaning it up and yet too often it is in the judgment of some that it is more fun to explode things than to build them up.  That is my concern today.  It does not matter at what level you are or what job you hold, be faithful and work for and not simply against the Church by making a mess where there does not need to be one.  Plus, my mother's wisdom for those who used her kitchen applies -- if you make a mess, clean it up!