While the Assembly of God has seen very limited growth, most of what passes for real life among the statistics of American Protestantism is with those whose size is very hard to determine. The non-denominational churches and networks of congregations do not have uniform definitions of membership or take attendance in the same way old Protestant churches once protected these statistics. Furthermore, they do not have membershiip numbers in the same way that the congregations of old designated who belonged and who did not. In most of these, attendance is a very different number than membership and generally larger than membership. But is this dynamism really due to reaching new people or is it shuffling of the deck of the numbers of Christians in America. Or, is it something else.
When you survey the numbers of congregations which have left the once sacred confines of their former denominational homes, you cannot account for those numbers in the small denominations which have spun off from these church bodies. In the ELCA, for example, the numbers that tell the sad story of its decline cannot be found in either the NALC or the LCMC which were the result of the conflict and division. What happened to them? They did not all close. Most of them became independent. They kept the legacy but without any real association to any other church body. The same could be said for any of those who left the once powerful seven sisters of Mainline Protestantism. Even large congregations within the Southern Baptists have left for one reason or another and have largely chosen the route of independence. In other words, they have joined the ranks of the non-denoms. There is a realignment going on which may account for some of the growth or seeming dynamism of this evangelical wing. For example, do you think that all congregations that left the United Methodist Church became part of the more conservative Global Methodist Church in 2022? No, some, perhaps even most, simply chose to become independent congregations with vague association to others but no defining connection.
As I have said before, the second largest church in America are those who used to be Christians and the second largest denominations of Christians are those who used to be Lutheran, Methodist, Presbyterian, etc... Many of them did not abandon every form of Christianity when they left. They simply chose to be spectators in the evangelical and non-denominational churches. This is less about loss and gain than about a realignment or shift. It happens with individuals and families and it is happening in congregations -- especially larger ones who prefer not to be bound by denominational rules. So before we are ready to concede that denominations are dead and the non-denoms are where it is at, let us make sure we notice that those who appear to be growing are not necessarily reaching anyone the traditional churches have failed to reach. A movement is taking place which makes it appear that the life and future of Christianity lies in the hands of those non-denominational churches but it may be something different. In any case, the news, while not good for traditional denominations, does not mean that evangelicals or an evangelical style Christianity is doing a better job evangelizing than traditional denominations did. It also means that this does not bode well for creedal and confessional Christianity in which orthodox confession of the Trinity and Jesus Christ is bound to denominational standards. It also means that something could cause another shift down the road. Stay tuned.

No comments:
Post a Comment