Saturday, November 21, 2026

Who are the evangelicals and non-denoms?

Now that the numbers of churches classified as evangelical and non-denominational include also those former mainline congregations which have voted to become independent, who exactly do we mean when we identify anything as an evangelical or non-denominational?  The problem of identification is exacerbated by the lack of any creedal consensus, any common theological tradition, any liturgical face, any common ministry, any common jurisdiction or structure above the local congregation, and any common standards for catechesis or membership.  So who are these people?  I have no doubt that many of them are well-meaning and well intentioned people, serious about their faith and committed to God but that does not do much to identify exactly what they believe or why they belong to this church or that.  In fact, my great fear is that their personal faith as well as where and why they belong represent two distinct circles which may or may not ever intersect.  Yet we continue to banter about the terms evangelical and non-denominational as if they actually mean something.  Words can only have meaning if they are defined and how do you define those terms in the sea of differences that range from charismatic and Pentecostal style churches to personality cults to formerly mainline churches who have given up on denominational promises?

In the city where I reside there is one Roman Catholic Church, three Lutheran churches, a smattering of variously identified Presbyterian churches, some Methodist churches, and some more typical to a Southern city than elsewhere (Church of Christ, Christian-Disciples of Christ, Church of God of Prophecy, AME, etc...).  Oh yes, and too many Baptist congregations of various persuasions to keep tabs on.  But even more than these are those with catchy, edgy names that do not betray a hint of what they believe or where they came from.  From Mosaic to LifePoint to 180 to whatever, non-denominational congregations who could also be described as evangelical predominate.  That said, who are they and what do they believe?  Who knows?  Short of sitting down and interviewing each to find out the answers to those questions, there is little to help you identify them as to creed, confession, history (usually recent), or connection to others.  Inevitably, they share a common worship style (casual, seeker) and music (contemporary Christian) but these are not quite hints to anything deeper about belief or structure.  They simply exist and fade and are reborn or replaced by new ones as they move in and out of the life cycle of congregations who might be called either non-denominational or evangelical.  They are a thing only because we allow them to exist within the vague definitions of those terms and not because those terms mean all that mean as keys to their identity or beliefs.

In the end, if someone belongs to a Lutheran congregation or a Methodist or Presbyterian or Roman Catholic or Anglican, I have some frame of reference to understand what they believe even if they personally are not enthusiastic of their denomination's confession.  But what can I surmise when someone says they belong to Pathfinder Church or Mosaic Church or LifePoint or Grace Community?   It means nothing to me and even though Lutherans like me like the term evangelical and sometimes are frustrated with our denomination I feel no kinship at all with evangelical non-denominational folk and especially with their preachers who may or may not be Trinitarian, modalist, charismatic, Pentecostal, prosperity gospel, Zionist, dispensationalist, and non-sacramental.  Lutherans intended by confession and early practice to be catholic Christians in doctrine and in life.  If we slip up or allow others with that name to abandon the practice while keeping the name, that is on us.  But those who fall into the evangelical non-denominational label can believe what they wish and practice as they desire without challenge and without any means of reining in those who violate the very meaning of what it is to be Christian.  So, I guess, I am kind of over the terms.  If they do not mean anything anymore then they have outlived their usefulness.

No comments: