Saturday, June 11, 2016

The Methodist Conundrum

Unlike most churches in America who began missions and retain a relationship with the fruits of that mission work, the United Methodist Church is not merely an American communion but has an organic relationship with mission churches it once began.  That has proven to be a mixed blessing for modern day Methodism.

Amid deep divisions over Scripture and the plethora of sexual issues facing most churches, The United Methodist Church has been brought to the brink of the unthinkable -- a divorce!

At the quadrennial United Methodist General Conference in mid-May, Bishop Bruce Ough was quick to deny that the leadership is "advancing or advocating any plan of separation or reorganization of the denomination."  Such a division might be unthinkable except that there is great pressure upon US Methodists to ordain LGBT clergy, to allow same-sex weddings, and to embrace the full spectrum of gender issues so often in the news here.  That is strongly opposed by conservatives within the US but most of all by the congregations in Africa.  Here is the growing edge of Methodism which refuses to be moved to favor the sexual issues considered normal by many American Methodists.  There are 12 million Methodists worldwide, including the 7.2 million in the U.S., but it is in Africa where Methodist growth is coming and where most of the opposition to the GLBT agenda is strongest.

Methodism has shrunk significantly in America and is but a shell of its former size.  Yet the pressure to conform to a liberal Christian social agenda remains strong -- even among those who acknowledge that it will not come without great cost.  Will Methodists decide to split up?  Who can tell!  Even if they paper over their differences in the short term, this division will not be overcome nor will the tensions disappear in the future.

1 comment:

John Joseph Flanagan said...

The UMC has been progressive for a very long time, and it is not surprising that there is a fissure in the foundation. I am surprised it took so long. Many of their individual congregations, apart from the mostly superficial debates over sexual identity and scripture, have long been activist and pro-gay, even asserting it as part of God's design. Never mind those verses which call it sin. The Methodists just ignore what the Old Bible teaches. It is not relevant to their own desired distinctives and the direction in which they prefer to go. It is always that way, isn't it? When a progressive church wishes to ignore what God's word plainly says, they will simply have one of their enlightened and smooth tongued theologians or respected Bishops write something that we can summarize as: "God did not say that." Or "God did not mean what He said about sexuality and homosexuality, about marriage, about gay unions. No. We simply, as Methodists, do not believe it. We will do things our way." Sound familiar? It should....It is Satan's argument and they lifted it out of his handbook.