Friday, March 13, 2015

Reclaiming Lutheran from legacy to identity. . .

Bad things happen when we are preoccupied.  That is exactly what happened in Lutheran higher education.  Our church body became preoccupied with things like the Battle for the Bible in the 1960s and 1970s, with harsh financial realities (from the 1970s to the present), with doctrinal disunity and practical chaos (from the 1970s to the present), with restructuring the Synodical ship (since the 1970s)...  The list could go on.  You get the drift.  Bad things happen when we are preoccupied with other things.

Among the Lutheran colleges and universities, what happened would fill a large book so we can't but touch on a few points here:
  • The system was undone and the schools that fed the seminaries and provided church work students became primarily colleges for laity with a tentative religious connection and their mission changed. . .
  • The costs of Lutheran colleges and universities mirrored the general explosive rise found among other private schools and even public institutions -- effectively pricing them out of the reach of much of the middle class especially when compared to the bargain prices of state sponsored schools. . .
  • The Synod assumed responsibility for a huge debt common to all LCMS colleges and universities and stopped being an effective means of support for the annual cost of their operation. . .
  • The Lutheran colleges and universities embarked on a necessary but very expensive capital projects program, even moving entire campuses from one location to another. . .
  • The faculties became more diverse religiously and politically and the distinctive character of Lutheran institutions and the unique Lutheran identity was tested to its very limits. . .
  • The focus of the administration of these schools shifted from institutional excellence and Lutheran integrity to fund raising (an essential task that eventually sucked all the air out of the boardrooms where their administration and regents met). . . 
  • The Lutheran colleges and universities developed their own constituencies and their connection to their church bodies that established and owned the campuses was weakened substantially. . .
  • The course work on the typical Lutheran college or university had little to distinguish it from many other institutions in which political liberalism, progressive social advocacy, and a skepticism of religion and faith predominated. . . 
Among these Lutheran institutions, the colleges and universities of the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod fared much better in retaining Lutheran identity than did the relatively independent schools of the ELCA.  However, without a prominent mission to serve the larger church by providing training for church worker students and without the chapel being more than a symbolic center of the faith, our institutions also suffered a sort of drift away from Lutheran connection and Lutheran identity.  Unlike the ELCA, the LCMS was determined to do something about this.

Read here for one of the first steps in the quest to reclaim and renew Lutheran identity in the universities of the LCMS.  It is a hopeful beginning to what will surely take a generation or more of renewed determination and patient effort. But it is a beginning.  Thanks be to God for the willingness of both the university presidents, the President of the Concordia University System, and the Synod to make this first public statement of commitment toward the larger goal of reclaiming these schools for the church.  Some will quibble that it is too little or too late but I am encouraged.  While I am sad that Bronxville, a school close to my heart, was not yet ready to sign on, I am convinced that this will be even better for the schools in the long run than it is for the church.  Lutheran is not a liability.  It is an asset -- even on the campus of an institution of higher learning.  Unless I am mistaken, it is on a university campus where Luther began.

4 comments:

Carl Vehse said...

"Read here for one of the first steps in the quest to reclaim and renew Lutheran identity in the universities of the LCMS.*

* "President Dr. Viji George of Concordia College—New York, Bronxville, has requested that his name be removed until his Board of Regents can consider the statement [to reclaim and renew Lutheran identity] in the universities of the LCMS."

Thus one CUS president appears to lack the confidence for his college embracing even the first step.

Paul said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Paul said...

Many institutions, likely including some in the CUS, will fail when the higher ed bubble bursts, and it won't be all bad. Smaller liberal arts schools are already shuttering, and the trend will continue until larger state institutions dominate the landscape even further.

In my opinion a strategic retreat from our weaker institutions along with the development of new models for intentionally Lutheran higher ed - minus the baggage of enrollment driven financing, bloated spending and debt from extravagant facilities/amenities/athletic programs, and milquetoast confession of the faith. This would be difficult, painful, and messy, but it would put us on much better footing to provide faithful and rigorous higher ed options to confessional Lutherans in the coming generations.

Can we be too preoccupied with saving institutions that we don't focus on other things that would actually meet the needs the CUS is intended to meet but no longer does?

Kirk Skeptic said...

how about small schools like Grove City College and Hillsdale College, which refuse federal funding yet prosper? Part of the cos of education is the large number of administrative assitants to the assistant administrators, course work that doesn't belong in college (remedial, etc), and luxurious (by the standards when I was in college) housing. Costs can be cut by excising fat, and that will make our schools more competitive. You can't be a pup and expect to run with the big dogs.