Monday, April 19, 2021

The changing face of membership. . .

Sitting around with pastors complaining about the pandemic and what it has done to our congregations is something that does little to fix the problem but the venting is not without its own benefit.  It was during one of those conversations that an idea popped into my head -- though I am sure I am not alone in thinking this.  It began with glowing reports of how many people were watching services online from one parish.  The pastor jokingly suggested that they had more people in church online than they had ever had in church in person ever before.  The number was in the thousands. So, the joke went, maybe it would be better if they never had in person worship.  Of course, this kind of gallows humor is stock and trade during the stresses of this pandemic.

It got me thinking, however, that there might be a market for an online only congregation.  It would be just the kind of congregation most people want -- cheap and easy to fund, one you can shut off and tune in again without anyone making some snide comment about missing you, one you can sleep through without having anyone notice, and one that asks hardly anything of you.  Who would not want to join such a congregation?  And that is the point.  How long before our congregations end up with an online presence that is larger and perhaps more significant than their in person operation?  How long before people in one state or country watching online will request to become official members of their online congregation?  Is it possible to have a congregation with a mostly online membership?

I think you already know what I think of such an endeavor.  So I will not repeat to you the bitter words I have for people who right now might be salivating at the prospect of such a church.  But I will suggest to you that the day is coming and perhaps already is when such congregations will exist -- even within denominations formally opposed to such virtual parishes.  It is an inevitable outcome of some of the poor choices we have made and the awful judgments rendered by and upon the churches during this pandemic.  Worship is not essential, online is the same as in person, sacraments may be handled remotely and virtually, and hits are the most important barometer of parish success.

Just think about it.  We could sell off all those properties expensive to maintain and run and have a church for the cost of some decent bandwidth.  We could get rid of all those in person programs and their volunteers and leave it to people to Facebook message or text each other for fellowship, zoom for instruction, and download for information.  It would be truly a virtual church!  The only people needed are the social media people and a few spare hours of some pastor's time.  We have the technology.  We could do it.

Remember what St. Paul said about the possible not being the beneficial?  I wonder how long it will be before the folks at the head of our churches either suggest what I have said or insist it should not be done.  How long will we want?  Some congregations and districts are fairly close to the whole idea of virtual parishes and virtual ministries.  And if we can do it, why would we not?  Therein lies the rub.  We would be pounding nails into our own coffins.  

The whole definition of a virtual church is that such a church is not real.  Real churches have real pastors, people, water for baptism, bread and wine for the Eucharist, and fellowship that flows from this though the assembly and out into the world.  Oh well, I will be retired by the time this really catches on and maybe I can supplement my retirement income with some side gigs online.  I can work at my leisure and don't even have to wear pants.  The camera only needs a head shot, after all, and that is what the digital media is good at -- making real people into talking heads.  Perhaps the only one disappointed by this would be Jesus.  But we can outvote Him. 

4 comments:

Timothy Carter said...

I faithfully attended "0n-line church" for almost a year before I got both shots. I have underlying health problems and at high risk for COVID.
I have been back at "in person" worship for 3 weeks now, once with Sunday School for "Here I Stand" Sunday.
"In Person" Liturgy is much to be preferred. I could really feel "the Cloud of Witnesses" as we Sang and communed and worshipped God and heard God speak to us through the Liturgy. It was good to be home.
Timothy Carter,
Simple country Deacon. Kingsport, TN.

John Joseph Flanagan said...

I can understand your anxiety, and your concerns about too many Christians moving to "virtual" worship, abandoning in-person church services. It is a serious problem indeed, but it is symptom of spiritual malaise across the land, pandemic lock downs, and forced isolation which has greatly affected people negatively, and increased psychological issues in our population. To the lawless Democrats and their supporters, the pandemic was a beneficial crisis. How else could they secure their power? Locking churches and limiting the assembly of people under the draconian rules they imposed so quickly. It is a very serious situation because the Left is on the move, and the goal is to reduce and diminish religious freedom. Remember that history shows that most people fall into line, and only the most dedicated resist. But this is as the Bible teaches and affirms: Only a remnant will remain faithful. The rest will fall away. The tree of Christianity is bring pruned, and the church is being purged. Knowing this, we need to pray for the strength to endure, and stand with the remnant.

John Joseph Flanagan said...

I can understand your anxiety, and your concerns about too many Christians moving to "virtual" worship, abandoning in-person church services. It is a serious problem indeed, but it is symptom of spiritual malaise across the land, pandemic lock downs, and forced isolation which has greatly affected people negatively, and increased psychological issues in our population. To the lawless Democrats and their supporters, the pandemic was a beneficial crisis. How else could they secure their power? Locking churches and limiting the assembly of people under the draconian rules they imposed so quickly. It is a very serious situation because the Left is on the move, and the goal is to reduce and diminish religious freedom. Remember that history shows that most people fall into line, and only the most dedicated resist. But this is as the Bible teaches and affirms: Only a remnant will remain faithful. The rest will fall away. The tree of Christianity is bring pruned, and the church is being purged. Knowing this, we need to pray for the strength to endure, and stand with the remnant.

Unknown said...

Yes, yes!!! Well said.